Who was the first audition speculation

[Sugar Mouse]

Originally Posted by SteveMacD

That’s not at all the intention of this thread. I started it. It was supposed to be a humorous guess at who the mystery audition was.

Huh? You actually started this by proposing Rob Thomas and Dave Grohl even though there is zero evidence that either was ever considered. Then you proposed Richard Thompson. And then you object to others proposing similar names. This "Lindsey Ledge" is truly an alternative universe ...