IYD - Rank the Songs

[Jondalar]

We are ranking these songs, but I put this thing on shuffle and all these songs are just great. There is sooo much variety. It's like listening to the radio. You never get bored. I think today after my fandome was over, I finally started to appreciate this album for what it really is --- very, solid songs across all radio formats. It's really special. Her and Dave managed to make really good songs in each genre. I'm really digging this album. It's just a good job across all genres.

[tabruns]

Originally Posted by Jondalar

We are ranking these songs, but I put this thing on shuffle and all these songs are just great. There is sooo much variety. It's like listening to the radio. You never get bored. I think today after my fandome was over, I finally started to appreciate this album for what it really is --- very, solid songs across all radio formats. It's really special. Her and Dave managed to make really good songs in each genre. I'm really digging this album. It's just a good job across all genres.

I feel the same way, which makes the review from Slant magazine all the more bizarre. I literally can't fathom that review. He might as well have told me that the sky is red, water is dry, and up is down. :P

[henryscutter]

Originally Posted by Jondalar

We are ranking these songs, but I put this thing on shuffle and all these songs are just great. There is sooo much variety. It's like listening to the radio. You never get bored. I think today after my fandome was over, I finally started to appreciate this album for what it really is --- very, solid songs across all radio formats. It's really special. Her and Dave managed to make really good songs in each genre. I'm really digging this album. It's just a good job across all genres.

That is how I feel. I am not dissapointed by any of the songs on this album. I freakin love this cd and I dont skip anything. I just got the chance to listen to IYD on a long road trip we had it cranked up and it was awesome. Im really getting into Moonlight, IYD, Annabel Lee,You may be the one, New Orleans, Everybody Loves You, and Italian Summer but like I said I adore everything.

[wildheart048]

I've wanted to do this everyday since the thread started, but I just can't seem to prioritize the songs!
I THINK Italian Summer is my favorite
but I really, really love (in the Album order...I guess with a gun to my head, I'd have to say they'd be at number two...and I'd probably get shot) For What It's Worth, In Your Dreams, New Orleans, Moonlight, Everybody loves You & You May Be The One


Cheaper Than Free would be next followed by Annabel Lee
Ghost Are Gone
and coming up in the rear are Wide Sargasso Sea and Soldier's Angel

[Hippocampus]

As plenty have said, it's quite hard to rank these songs, probably still too early. Songs from 04-11 are interchangeable for me at this point.

01. Annabel Lee
02. New Orleans
03. Moonlight
04. For What It's Worth
05. Wide Sargasso Sea
06. Italian Summer
07. In Your Dreams
08. Secret Love
09. Soldier's Angel
10. You May Be The One
11. Cheaper Than Free
12. Everybody Loves You
13. Ghosts Are Gone


I can't include My Heart yet because I'm waiting June 27th for the UK edition

[JesusRumours]

For me:
1. Moonlight (A Vampire's Dream)
2. For What It's Worth
3. Wide Sargasso Sea
4. Everybody Loves You
5. Anabel Lee
6. New Orleans
7. Italian Summer
8. In Your Dreams
9. Cheaper Than Free
10. You May Be The One
11. Soldier's Angel
12. Ghosts Are Gone
13. Secret Love

Yes, Secret Love is my least favorite, but it's still awesome! Oh and I haven't heard My Heart yet