American Idol 9: Discussion & Poll (FM Theme Night?)

[jannieC]

Siobhan and Crystal are my favorites, followed by Michael. I *really* liked Alex and hate he got voted off. There was an innocence about him that really was refreshing. I didn't get an idiot-savant vibe from him, though I did question the haircut and the way he bit his lip a lot.

In all seriousness now- Tim Urban makes me sick. I wish I could secretly video-tape my husband imitating him and then post it here. The way he kept saying "wow" the other night was ridiculous. I thought some of his vocals on Hallelujiah were okay but not at all like contestants in the past. His affect is gross and the way he tries to act humble- ew.

Oh, and I thought Didi's(?) version of Rhiannon was actually kind of lovely. I was surprised.