Mirage Live SOTM comment

[David]

Originally Posted by iamnotafraid

As much as I would like to hear her do it live again, do you think she could do the song justice?

"Justice" is subjective in this case, I guess (for example, some people think she is perfect on If Anyone Falls from Soundstage but I think it sounds awful).

All we know for certain is that Nicks isn't going to sing it like that, & the band isn't going to play it like that. Nothing from that night or that tour sounds the same today, singer or band: The Chain, Go Your Own Way, Rhiannon, Landslide, Second Hand News, Don't Stop, etc.

[animal]

Originally Posted by David

All we know for certain is that Nicks isn't going to sing it like that, & the band isn't going to play it like that. Nothing from that night or that tour sounds the same today, singer or band: The Chain, Go Your Own Way, Rhiannon, Landslide, Second Hand News, Don't Stop, etc.

It needs to be released on DVD

[wheart]

Originally Posted by David

"Justice" is subjective in this case, I guess (for example, some people think she is perfect on If Anyone Falls from Soundstage but I think it sounds awful).

All we know for certain is that Nicks isn't going to sing it like that, & the band isn't going to play it like that. Nothing from that night or that tour sounds the same today, singer or band: The Chain, Go Your Own Way, Rhiannon, Landslide, Second Hand News, Don't Stop, etc.

I especially miss the way Landslide was done back in the old days!

[michelej1]

Originally Posted by David

All we know for certain is that Nicks isn't going to sing it like that, & the band isn't going to play it like that.

Enchanted and If Anyone Falls aren't holding up in concert anymore. Although when the music stops and she does the "twilight. dreamtime. somewhere" chant, that's pretty exciting.

Michele

[skcin]

Originally Posted by David

"Justice" is subjective in this case, I guess (for example, some people think she is perfect on If Anyone Falls from Soundstage but I think it sounds awful).

All we know for certain is that Nicks isn't going to sing it like that, & the band isn't going to play it like that. Nothing from that night or that tour sounds the same today, singer or band: The Chain, Go Your Own Way, Rhiannon, Landslide, Second Hand News, Don't Stop, etc.

For sure on both points. I think IFA is terribly monotone & dull. I do enjoy the acapella part at the end.

Originally Posted by michelej1

Enchanted and If Anyone Falls aren't holding up in concert anymore. Although when the music stops and she does the "twilight. dreamtime. somewhere" chant, that's pretty exciting.

Michele

Enchanted seems slowed down to me these days, like it's a record being played at the wrong speed. I used to like it for its upbeat, happy vibe cuz it seemed to get people into the show, even if they didn't know the song. Not so much anymore. I find it dull.

[AliceLover]

Originally Posted by michelej1

Enchanted and If Anyone Falls aren't holding up in concert anymore. Although when the music stops and she does the "twilight. dreamtime. somewhere" chant, that's pretty exciting.

Michele

I always love If Anyone Falls. The melodies never get old to me. I am so glad it has become a staple in her solo set.