Thrown Down and McDonald's

[David]

Originally Posted by Serrart

It's a blunt arrow IMO. His irony doesn't bite in this case, it's subtle emotional potential drowns in the too clever melody. There's all his reserch to perfect form that sometimes brings him to an annoying academism. The text works, the music works, but not together, I think.

Most of these songs don't matter to me in terms of who likes what. But a small few of them--like this one--do. If people don't like it, I want to hear why.

So just for replying, I'm going to post some Milstein playing heavenly Bach for you. But first I must upload it.