American Idol: Season 5

[Sorceress]

I officially love Mandisa. I really do. Katharine didn't do badly either, though she looked like she had just walked in from the grocery store, or class, or a trip to the mall. She didn't look bad, but I guess I'm expecting some attempt at style. I suppose I should appreciate that she doesn't look like she was attacked by crazed stylists like some of the others do. Paris was disappointing and Lisa was BORING. Can those two pick a decent song please?

Ayla and Kinnik were the worst tonight, though probably it will be Melissa and Kinnik going home. Though I like her, I have to say that Melissa had a look of desperation to her tonight when she was performing.