American Idol: Season 5

[cliffdweller]

Ace, Peter Brady, Kevin, and Crooner all sucked! They need the boot. And what's with a 16 year old singing "Lady" anyway? That was absolutely ridiculous. I laughed and laughed.

Taylor, man, I'm rooting for him but that performance was not all that great. I love that song though.

Gideon, Elliott, and Chris were the best. Chris's performance was outstanding.

I thought Sway did a good job and I don't normally like him! I thought the judges were waaaaay too critical of his performance. I mean, they trashed it basically and then let little hobbit gnome (Kevin) off with a slap on the wrist (he MURDERED I Heard it Through the Grapevine btw). I thought Sway sounded just like Stevie Wonder .