"Without You" Will be a New FM Song

[Johnny Stew]

Originally Posted by jkmaletic

I have this on a boot cd, but was it actually part of the original Polydor BN release or was it a demo that never made it onto the record? I can't remember..

It wasn't a part of the original album, but it's often tacked onto bootleg copies.

Even though Stevie keeps questioning why it didn't make it onto 'Buckingham Nicks,' I think it was actually demoed for the second album they were working on when Fleetwood Mac came calling.

[WildHearted]

Originally Posted by Johnny Stew

Even though Stevie keeps questioning why it didn't make it onto 'Buckingham Nicks,' I think it was actually demoed for the second album they were working on when Fleetwood Mac came calling.

Lindsey thinks so too.

I've seen online that it was supposedly written by both of them?

[elle]

Originally Posted by Johnny Stew

It wasn't a part of the original album, but it's often tacked onto bootleg copies.

Even though Stevie keeps questioning why it didn't make it onto 'Buckingham Nicks,' I think it was actually demoed for the second album they were working on when Fleetwood Mac came calling.

Originally Posted by WildHearted

Lindsey thinks so too.

yup, Lindsey keeps saying in the interviews every time when Stevie brings up that she doesn't know why it was not on the original BN "cause it wasn't recorded yet". you can see him saying that in one of those videos from the series they couple of weeks ago, and she replies "you know, i think you are right!"

[bombaysaffires]

Originally Posted by elle

yup, Lindsey keeps saying in the interviews every time when Stevie brings up that she doesn't know why it was not on the original BN "cause it wasn't recorded yet". you can see him saying that in one of those videos from the series they couple of weeks ago, and she replies "you know, i think you are right!"

I thought he said it "wasn't written yet"

[elle]

Originally Posted by bombaysaffires

I thought he said it "wasn't written yet"

i think you are right! i kept going back in between written and recorded b/c i couldn't remember which was it. he said the same thing it that his and hers RS interview so that might be the easy place to check.

[elle]

so to be honest, while i'm happy that they are finally releasing a song, i'm a bit disappointed that we will not hear a completely new song that we know nothing about yet. but hopefully once they release the first one, other 2 will follow in a short succession.

[michelej1]

Originally Posted by elle

so to be honest, while i'm happy that they are finally releasing a song, i'm a bit disappointed that we will not hear a completely new song that we know nothing about yet. but hopefully once they release the first one, other 2 will follow in a short succession.

Once they release Sad Angel, you'll be cured of any desire to hear completely new songs.


Michele

[WildHearted]

Originally Posted by elle

so to be honest, while i'm happy that they are finally releasing a song, i'm a bit disappointed that we will not hear a completely new song that we know nothing about yet. but hopefully once they release the first one, other 2 will follow in a short succession.

I'm wondering if we will get this one first, though?

Did they specify? I thought she said they just decided to put it in the FM "wicker basket" with the others.

Also nice to hear her say that maybe they could get another song recorded - good that she's at least open to the idea of doing more new music.

[Bandon]

Originally Posted by elle

so to be honest, while i'm happy that they are finally releasing a song, i'm a bit disappointed that we will not hear a completely new song that we know nothing about yet. but hopefully once they release the first one, other 2 will follow in a short succession.

People are always saying they want to hear new studio versions of demos instead of saying they want to hear great new material. The new versions of demos can be good, and I am curious to hear them, but I know the songs already and would rather hear a great new song. The one exception for me was the revised version of Planets of the Universe, which was killer.