2012 Fleetwood Mac Contest

[elle]

although i think the non-hit idea might be interesting in general, i like separate best-of for each songwriter even better.

my reasoning: b/c of uneven numbers of fans for each songwriter among registered members on this board, i don't follow polls where songs from 3 songwriters are pitted against each other. in such polls, songs that are the most interesting to me tend to be eliminated fast.

[MikeInNV]

Originally Posted by elle

although i think the non-hit idea might be interesting in general, i like separate best-of for each songwriter even better.

my reasoning: b/c of uneven numbers of fans for each songwriter among registered members on this board, i don't follow polls where songs from 3 songwriters are pitted against each other. in such polls, songs that are the most interesting to me tend to be eliminated fast.

We could split out the non-hit favorites for each songwriter separately.

[elle]

Originally Posted by MikeInNV

We could split out the non-hit favorites for each songwriter separately.

sounds like a nice solution to me!

[MacFan92]

I'm torn! They're all good. I'll have to think it over.

[poetinmyheart]

Originally Posted by MacFan92

I'm torn! They're all good. I'll have to think it over.

Me too. Will have a think on it. Forerunner at the moment is choice B - non hit.

[MacShadowsBall]

Originally Posted by elle

although i think the non-hit idea might be interesting in general, i like separate best-of for each songwriter even better.

my reasoning: b/c of uneven numbers of fans for each songwriter among registered members on this board, i don't follow polls where songs from 3 songwriters are pitted against each other. in such polls, songs that are the most interesting to me tend to be eliminated fast.

Glad to see you interested in the next contest. I remember our discussions on the one back in 2010.

Generally, as long as there is a Stevie song in the poll, it will win regardless.

Originally Posted by MikeInNV

We could split out the non-hit favorites for each songwriter separately.

That's the way I was thinking. Check back on my threads from August-Dec of 2010 for the favorite song contest. I broke up each album by the 3 different vocalists, got a winner for each vocalist on that album, and then had those songs battle for favorite song from that album.

[Blueletter18]

I voted for the best-of lists- it would be nice to have a well-rounded compilation put together for each songwriter.

[Blueletter18]

Originally Posted by elle

sounds like a nice solution to me!

Me too, that would be a great compromise!

[McTrouble]

Choice A - Best of.....

Can we do all these polls one after the other?

[vivfox]

Originally Posted by McTrouble

Can we do all these polls one after the other?

This is MacShadowsBall's thread. Ofcourse she'll get around to making a poll of all three. That's what she does best: pole dancing.

[TerraRhiannon]

I love all of these ideas but... I voted for non hit. I think it would be interesting to see what could come out on top!

[PenguinHead]

Originally Posted by vivfox

This is MacShadowsBall's thread. Ofcourse she'll get around to making a poll of all three. That's what she does best: pole dancing.

Perhaps there should be a contest of our favorite poll.

I think that the concept of contests that pitch songs against songs are ridiculous. But to each its own. Over time I've lost interest in them. Yet interestingly, I still have interest in poles. (insert smirky smile here).