Say You Will - Analyze Your Least Favorites

[MacShadowsBall]

Well we're getting to the end of the first part of the least favorite song battles! Here we start with Fleetwood Mac's last album...


Bad lyrics -

Christine come back, please!! -

Should've been a hit single -

Add this song, remove that one -

Much better performed live -

Overall least favorite -

[bluefox4000]

Bad lyrics - Peacekeeper, Silver Girl

Christine come back, please!! - The whole Friggin' affair suffers without her

Should've been a hit single - Come........just saying it......really don't care. About this train wreak of a project

Add this song, remove that one - Can I cheat and say remove Stevie's harmonies from bucky's songs

Much better performed live - Come

Overall least favorite - Silver Girl.

As you can clearly tellv.....My disdain for this turkey runs deep... Sorry peoples.

Mick

[mezzoforte]

Bad lyrics - Silver Girl

Christine come back, please!! - Rarely a moment in the album I'm not thinking this.

Should've been a hit single - Steal Your Heart Away

Add this song, remove that one - Can I remove two instead? WTWCT and Silver Girl.

Much better performed live - Say Goodbye

Overall least favorite - Silver Girl

[darklinensuit]

Bad lyrics – Compared to some of the production and vocals, lyrics are the least of the problems with this album.

Christine come back, please!! – I’d much rather have heard Christine’s voice instead of Lindsey’s snake-voice on “Illume” and “Running through the Garden”.

Should've been a hit single – “Miranda”

Add this song, remove that one – Cut “Smile at You”, add a good version of “Smile at You”

Much better performed live – “Come”

Overall least favorite – “Red Rover”


- Jake

[jbrownsjr]

Originally Posted by darklinensuit

Bad lyrics

Add this song, remove that one – Cut “Smile at You”, add a good version of “Smile at You”



- Jake

Haha!! You're spot on again! You crack me up when it matters most.

[LilyRose]

I dug out my SYW album last night and listened to it for the first time in years. I actually ended up liking many of the songs a lot more than I remembered...maybe that's because they were kind of new again after not listening for so long?

Anyhoo

Bad lyrics - Silver Girl - I detest this song

Christine come back, please!! - Every. Single. Song. (That she's not already on.) I never realized how much I loved Christine until she was gone.

Should've been a hit single - Thrown Down, Steal Your Heart Away

Add this song, remove that one - Remove Peacekeeper and SYW, add Down on Rodeo and Not Make Believe.

Much better performed live - Come?

Overall least favorite - Silver Girl

ETA: I also think there are way too many songs on SYW. Take about 8 of them off altogether.

[holidayroad]

Bad lyrics - unsure

Christine come back, please!! - There should have been Christine songs replacing Running Through the Garden, Bleed To Love Her, and one of the 'goodbye' songs.

Should've been a hit single - Thrown Down

Add this song, remove that one - Remove the redo of Bleed to Love Her. It was fine on The Dance. Also, remove this version of Steal Your Heart Away and replace it with the one on the 1997 Best Buy The Dance Tour CD.

Much better performed live - unsure

Overall least favorite - Running Through the Garden

[McTrouble]

Bad lyrics - Illume

Chris, come back, please!! - Love the album and the line-up is just fine without Chris

Should've been a hit single - WTWCT and SYHA

Add this song, remove that one - None to add, but remove Illume and a couple more of Stevie's

Much better performed live - Come, WTWCT

Overall least fav - Illume

[ontheEdgeof17]

Bad lyrics - Come

Christine come back, please!! - Destiny Rules and What's The World Coming To

Should've been a hit single - Thrown Down

Add this song, remove that one - Remove Come.

Much better performed live - Say Goodbye

Overall least favorite - Come

[darklinensuit]

[QUOTE=holidayroad;1000759]

Originally Posted by MacShadowsBall

Christine come back, please!! - There should have been Christine songs replacing Running Through the Garden

Overall least favorite - Running Through the Garden

I think the RAL outtake is far superior, but RTTG is still my favorite on SYW.

Originally Posted by ontheEdgeof17

Remove Come.

Must...not...make...Lewinsky dress joke...


- Jake

[MacShadowsBall]

Start PMing your predictions for least fav Stevie, Lindsey, and least fav song from Say You Will.

[McTrouble]

[QUOTE=darklinensuit;1000780][QUOTE=holidayroad;1000759]

I think the RAL outtake is far superior, but RTTG is still my favorite on SYW.



Must...not...make...Lewinsky dress joke...

How wude - but very funny!

[michelej1]

Bad lyrics - Silver Girl

Christine come back, please!! - Whole album

Should've been a hit single - Thrown Down, EFO

Add this song, remove that one - Not Make Believe, Silver Girl

Much better performed live - I don't think anything sounded better live

Overall least favorite - Silver Girl and RTTG

[vivfox]

Originally Posted by michelej1

Much better performed live - I don't think anything sounded better live

I'm really suprised to hear you say this. I love FM live. Every song is enhanced to the umpth degree.

[michelej1]

Originally Posted by vivfox

I'm really suprised to hear you say this. I love FM live. Every song is enhanced to the umpth degree.

I wasn't putting down any of the live songs. I just don't think any of them sound better than the studio version. That doesn't mean I think they are dogs. There are none that I wanted to hurry up and end. And we're only talking about SYW, too. There are plenty of other songs that I think sound better in concert than they do on the album, beginning with ISA.

Michele