Australian review of In Your Dreams

[DoubtfulMiracle]

Originally Posted by Jondalar

guess I'm a little confused on how to take the headline

I was too. My heart sank when I read it the first time, but in the context of the whole review, I'm with Louie - it's definitely a favourable thing.

But all these reviews do is leave me wanting more! I fear though that if they were all as specific and as in-depth as we wanted them to be, they would run for a good few pages

And from the looks of other Herald Sun album reviews, its 3 out of 5 stars. Seems like a hard marker to me.