Ellen Becomes 4th Idol Judge

[Travis]

Originally Posted by vivfox

B4 the show ever aired Paula was a has-been. Now she'll fade into the woodwork and become a has-been once again.

That's pretty rude. Have you accomplished in your life as much as Paula has? Nobody stays at the top forever. Paula is an ultra talented woman and sometimes in life it's all about timing. Paula would not have landed the AI gig if she was just a nobody that wasn't talented, she got the gig because of her talent and experience as a performer.


Ellen isn't a singer, dancer or a songwriter (trained or untrained). I like Ellen very much, but this choice is just wrong on all counts.