American Idol: Season 6

[Richard B]

Originally Posted by skcin

Richard, are you drunk? It's a singing contest & what happened last night did not truly reflect their talent. Sabrina may wail, but the bitch can sing IN TUNE, unlike Antonella. Good riddance to that ditzy broad. Sanjaya is creepy, reminds me of Michael Jackson (and not in a good way.)

I do totally agree with you that Haley sucks though.

Sadly, I was not drunk. Funny you call it a singing contest. The judges, when they feel their is an "upset" always say "this is a singing contest." But at the same time, they will make comments on their clothes, hair, style and once in awhile even say "it's the whole package." Bit of a mixed message don'tcha think?

I know Antonella is not the best singer and I don't care because she sure is nice to watch (I'm a pig I know, but damn she's HOT) and she's pleasant enough when she sings. Although, it kills me when they make those poor people sing after their told to go home. So cruel.

Aladdin/Sanjaya is very effeminate, but he is 17 and a gentle soul. I really don't mind him, he sings happy, peace, love songs. He is the most unusual contestant in the bunch, which makes him stand out. And cause he's so weird, you either love him or hate him.

The bottom line: Melinda Doolittle is gonna win and my front runner and she's so amazing vocally, not to mention so humble and very cute in her way. Although I love LaKisha, Stephanie and Brandon (in that order) as well. They're fun to watch and listen to.

Edit: How could I forget Gina and Blake (after my above list of favs). They're cool too. Just please, Gina, no more Heart songs.