American Idol: Top 12

[skcin]

Originally Posted by cliffdweller

Chris was definitely the best. I didn't hear THAT much strain on his vocals---I think Simon made too much of it.

Katherine butchered Against All Odds, I was seriously cringing it was so bad. Her second song was okay, but all in all I thought her two performances were pretty bland and boring.

Elliott was good as usual. I liked his second song better. Never liked that "On Broadway" song anyway.

I still like Taylor's voice, but yes, his schtick is played. And could he please stop saying "soul patrol?" What does that even mean anyway?

I thought Paris did a good job with "Kiss," but then again it's hard to go wrong with Prince .

I agree with your entire post. Katharine was so off it was painful - her vocals, her timing. Terrible.

I thought Taylor did a great job on "Something" (dear God, I just realized that I'm not sure that's the actual title of that song. Sorry if I screwed up.) But "Play that funky music" was a joke. Sounded like me & my drunk friends doing bad karaoke.



I think Kat should go, but I think Elliot or Paris will go.