American Idol: Top 12

[cliffdweller]

Originally Posted by Brwn_eyes0511

Chris.. picked THE WRONG SONG.. and he was doing some crazy "Stevie Nicks - goat-ish" thing with his voice.. and it didn't work well, IMO.. Wasn't the worst of the night.. but nowhere near the best.

"goatish"

I agree with this, I thought it was, as Simon said, self-indulgent and I think it's gonna hurt him in the voting that he chose such an unrecognizable song. That said, he'll probably still be safe. And what was with his eyeliner last night? Dude can't pull off make-up so he shouldn't even go there.

I thought Bucky's song worked too, my husband HATED it, but that's mainly because he hates that song and he hates Bucky's voice so , but I thought it worked.

Taylor was ridiculous! Come on dude, stop acting like a clown already. I like it when he just sits there and sings and doesn't try to dance, because THAT? is horrific and sad

I liked Paris too, Katherine was boring, and Pickler chose a song WAAAAAAAY out of her range. She and Ace chose songs that were too big for them---Ace can't sing and Kellie's vocal range can't handle B.R. that's all there is to it.

Elliott was GRRRRRRRRREAT! I thoroughly enjoyed him last night.