American Idol: Season 5

[JazmenFlowers]

Originally Posted by cliffdweller

I know, that's weird. And he keeps giving Lisa props but criticizing her poor song choices. It's like, first they talk about how talented homegirl is then then sh*t on the songs she performs. Doesn't make sense. I thought she was beyond boring and forgettable, but Simon and Paula keep talking about how talented she is, and how she'll "sail through to the next round," despite the fact that her song choices suck and she's basically just boring up there. The judges should only give comments about the performance at hand, not about how talented someone is, I mean, if certain contestants keep doing sucky boring songs then how does that display their talent? It makes no sense.

exactly. then in the next breath complain about Ayla's song choice, even though they said it was a good choice for her...huh?