Once again, a bunch of the girls blend together for me at the start of the season. Ayla, Heather, Stevie were all blah, I can tell them apart.
Becky - sounded like she was pretending to sing. Did that just make sense to anyone? It was like me, belting something out in my car even though I have no clue how to actually sing. Ya know?
But she's hot, so she'll probably make it through this week.
Brenna - she can just go away now. Are you kidding me? "You Are the Sunshine of My Life?" Seriously? First of all, you want to WOW people, especially your first week & she did NOT. Secondly, that song kind of blows. Thirdly, her voice kind of blows. Fourthly, I just don't like the bitch.
Kinnik - Strange - I thought she was good at first, then I thought she wasn't, then I thought she was good again. She's OK, she can stay for a while.
My favorites:
Mandisa - kicked the **** out of "Never." I was so excited when she said that's what she'd be singing. Fantastic.
Pickler - brave for trying Martina, and I think she was great except those high notes: "How faaaaaar, do I have to go to make you
understand..." That little lift in "understand" was funky every time.
Lisa - it appears this chick will be able to sing anything. Love her.
Melissa - She sang Faith, which is risky, but I thought she did really well. I was actually moved by her performance. I hope she doesn't get lost in the sea of "which girl with the long brown hair? There's like 4 of them."
Paris - what a little spitfire, what a performer, what a VOICE! "Midnight Train to Georgia" is one of my favorite songs ever, and she nailed it.
Katherine - Might be my favorite of the night along with Paris, I liked her a lot. Again, hope she doesn't get lost.
I voted for my 6 faves, the only ones I couldn't get through for by 10:40pm were Paris & Pickler.
02-22-2006, 01:02 PM
Threaded Mode