American Idol: Season 5

[ontheEdgeof17]

Originally Posted by jannieC

I had an American Idol revelation, though. At the end, when they showed everyone singing Fame, I noticed that it included several people who had auditioned with other songs. So, do they have whoever makes it to Randy, Paula, and Simon do several songs, then use what they think is best for the show? You all probably noticed this in maybe, season one, but I'm slow. It took the performance of Rhonetta ("You think I'm gonna drink off you, motherf*cker?) to light the bulb in my head.

Here's what I think. I think they choose a song at each stop and make everyone sing it....not in front of the judges....in another room...just for laughs....Last week was Lady Marmalade......this week Fame.

Just my thought.