So I just listened to Why for the first time.

[Montclare]

Originally Posted by FuzzyPlum

In retrospect that Buckingham & Nicks version is actually pretty horrible really.
This version still misses Bob Weston's guitar playing but Bob Welch captures the emotion of the song much, much better than Lindsey Buckingham in my opinion.
A pretty intense last ten seconds or so.

Odd, I feel the exact opposite. I feel Lindsey's slower guitar captures the emotion better; Bob's feels more like going through the motions to me. And I love the harmonies with Lindsey and Stevie. Count me as a fan of the Rumours band version of this one.