Band Face Off - Semifinals 2

[ryan8472]

Carly Simon.

[markolas]

Gads, how could anyone pick Carly Simon over Joni Mitchell? She's a talentless hack compared to Joni.

[shackin'up]

Originally Posted by The Tower

Although, Patti singing "Revenge" is something Joni could never pull off.

So I picked Patti.

[SuzeQuze]

Originally Posted by EnchantedSLN

This one is easy. I hate Carly Simon and could never really get into Joni's stuff. I don't know all that much Patti Smith, but what I've heard was just alright. Bonnie all the way!

Rock it sista! She is something else.

[Moony]

Originally Posted by markolas

Gads, how could anyone pick Carly Simon over Joni Mitchell? She's a talentless hack compared to Joni.

She's a talentless hack compared to almost everybody, IMO. I've never understood her popularity. Ick.

[UnwindedDreams]

Originally Posted by Moony

She's a talentless hack compared to almost everybody, IMO. I've never understood her popularity. Ick.

She's also a horse

[EnchantedSLN]

Originally Posted by SuzeQuze

Rock it sista! She is something else.

"The Dimming of the Day" live makes me melt! Her voice oozes heartache like no one else's. Sometimes I think her writing can be a bit hokey (the fun, bluesy stuff), but her guitar playing is amazing and when it all comes together she really nails it.

I actually liked Bonnie before I liked Stevie. When I was little I saw her on tv and thought she looked like Rogue from the X-men, which automatically made her cool