Survivor: Members of FM - ROUND 13 RESULTS

[SteveMacD]

Originally Posted by David

Which of the following FM songs contain no minor chord? (Choose three)


3. Angel

immunity to McVie



Upon further review, I think this is a loaded question.

Originally Posted by David

Which of the following FM songs contain no minor chord? (Choose three)

1. You Make Loving Fun
2. Blue Letter
3. Angel
4. Songbird
5. I Don't Want to Know
6. Bella Donna
7. The Wild Heart

Well, 6 & 7 aren't Fleetwood Mac songs, so those can automatically be thrown out.

From experience, YMLF and "Songbird" both have minor chords. However, I've seen IDWTK and "Blue Letter" both written with minor chords, though in my "Fleetwood Mac Anthology" book, IDWTK does not appear to have any minor chords, but those books aren't always reliable. Hence why I chose "Angel," which I've NEVER seen transcribed with a minor chord. However, I'm only assuming that David's referring to the Stevie Nicks song, not the Bob Welch song, as he listed only "Rumours" era songs. So I could be wrong, since the Welch song probably has a minor chord in it.

DAMN YOU OBERMAN AND ALL OF YOUR CONFUSING IMMUNITY QUESTIONS!!!

(Just kidding. You know we all love you )

[HomerMcvie]

Originally Posted by SteveMacD

immunity to McVie

I didn't see the three until I'd already jumped ship!

[Dark Angel]

Originally Posted by David

Which of the following FM songs contain no minor chord? (Choose three)

1. You Make Loving Fun
2. Blue Letter
3. Angel
4. Songbird
5. I Don't Want to Know
6. Bella Donna
7. The Wild Heart

I Don't Want To Know
Angel

At least according to all my songbooks, there are no three, and two songs are Stevie solo, not FM.

Anyway, if correct, immunity to Bob Welch.

[GypsySorcerer]

Let's just crown Dave Mason the winner already!

[HomerMcvie]

Originally Posted by SteveMacD

From experience, YMLF and "Songbird" both have minor chords. However, I've seen IDWTK and "Blue Letter" both written with minor chords, though in my "Fleetwood Mac Anthology" book, IDWTK does not appear to have any minor chords

The gray anthology book? I've got that one, although I've not seen it for years. It's in a closet....somewhere here.
I'm doing all these from memory, but I'm 99% sure I'm correct!
IDWTK-All B,F#,and E
Angel- all D,C,G
Wild Heart- hell, I've not listened to it for sooooo long, I can't remember the chords, BUT, you are correct that YMLF and Songbird both have minor chords. Bella Donna does too-G minor on the "no speed limit". And, Blue Letter goes from A to B minor, so that's out, too. So the third song has to be, by default, The Wild Heart.
How lazy am I, that I don't go into the next room, dig it out, and listen to it?

[SteveMacD]

Originally Posted by HomerMcvie

So the third song has to be, by default, The Wild Heart.

Which isn't a Fleetwood Mac song. The way the question was phrased, it was "Which FM song..." So, that would be disqualified.

[HomerMcvie]

Originally Posted by SteveMacD

Which isn't a Fleetwood Mac song. The way the question was phrased, it was "Which FM song..." So, that would be disqualified.

But he said, "choose three". Have you noticed all the Stevie trivia questions?
Let's get Greenie outta here this round!

[HomerMcvie]

Bye, oh long nailed one.

[chiliD]

I'm boycotting the rest of this f***ing thing.

[HomerMcvie]

Originally Posted by chiliD

I'm boycotting the rest of this f***ing thing.

I would honestly rather see McVie go this round, but I've seen the voting patterns.

[David]

Originally Posted by SteveMacD

Well, 6 & 7 aren't Fleetwood Mac songs, so those can automatically be thrown out.

Oh, that was a typo. I just meant pick all the songs on that list that had no minor chords. You guys are so literal-minded!

However, I've seen IDWTK and "Blue Letter" both written with minor chords

If you've seen IDWTK written with minor chords, it was written incorrectly!

However, I'm only assuming that David's referring to the Stevie Nicks song, not the Bob Welch song, as he listed only "Rumours" era songs.

As it so happens, pal, Bob's "Angel" is one of my favorites, although I totally wasn't thinking about it when I threw in "Angel."

So I could be wrong, since the Welch song probably has a minor chord in it.

It's chock-a-block full of minor 7ths.

I have just totally (inadvertently) screwed up this game! I feel like such a clown!

[David]

Originally Posted by HomerMcvie

Have you noticed all the Stevie trivia questions?

I want to encourage the Stevie-ites to play! Besides, Stevie trivia makes the best trivia. She's the Goddess!!

[SteveMacD]

Originally Posted by HomerMcvie

I would honestly rather see McVie go this round, but I've seen the voting patterns.

Like the fact he hasn't gotten a single vote against him during the whole game?

[HomerMcvie]

Originally Posted by David

Oh, that was a typo. I just meant pick all the songs on that list that had no minor chords. You guys are so literal-minded!
If you've seen IDWTK written with minor chords, it was written incorrectly!
As it so happens, pal, Bob's "Angel" is one of my favorites, although I totally wasn't thinking about it when I threw in "Angel."
It's chock-a-block full of minor 7ths.

I have just totally (inadvertently) screwed up this game! I feel like such a clown!

So David, what you're saying is that you meant for us to pick all the songs with no minor chords, correct? Like I did, correct? I'm a good boy, and answered your question correctly then, correct?

Emerald Eyes is a mystery.

[HomerMcvie]

Originally Posted by SteveMacD

Like the fact he hasn't gotten a single vote against him during the whole game?

Bob's only had two, afaik.