The White Album vs. Rumours

[KarmaContestant]

Originally Posted by amber

Welcome, I hope you have a good time!

Thanks, Amber, I have had many good times here already. I've been reading daily for nearly a year, and I always get a good laugh.

[Hawkeye]

Welcome Karma glad you're jumping in on my great thread

[Moony]

Rhiannon vs. Dreams

Landslide vs. Gold Dust Woman

Crystal vs. I Don't Want to Know

Monday Morning vs. Second Hand News

Blue Letter vs. Never Going Back Again

I'm So Afraid vs. Go Your Own Way

Sugar Daddy vs. Oh Daddy

Warm Ways vs. Songbird (ick!)

Say You Love Me vs. Don't Stop

Over My Head vs. You Make Loving Fun

World Turning vs. The Chain

I just don't like Rumours that much...

FM: 8
R: 3

[LikeAWillow]

Rhiannon vs. Dreams

Landslide vs. Gold Dust Woman

Crystal vs. I Don't Want to Know

Monday Morning vs. Second Hand News

Blue Letter vs. Never Going Back Again

I'm So Afraid vs. Go Your Own Way

Sugar Daddy vs. Oh Daddy

Warm Ways vs. Songbird

Say You Love Me vs. Don't Stop

Over My Head vs. You Make Loving Fun

World Turning vs. The Chain

FM: 7

Rumours: 4 Rumours as an album is so much better than its seperate parts IMO

~Marissa~

[sweetgypsygirl]

Rhiannon vs. Dreams

Landslide vs. Gold Dust Woman

Crystal vs. I Don't Want to Know (if Crystal was sung by Stevie, it would win this one, hands down!)

Monday Morning vs. Second Hand News

Blue Letter vs. Never Going Back Again

I'm So Afraidvs. Go Your Own Way

Sugar Daddy vs. Oh Daddy (ugh)

Warm Ways vs. Songbird

Say You Love Me vs. Don't Stop

Over My Head vs. You Make Loving Fun

World Turning vs. The Chain

[Miss Vicky]

Rhiannon vs. Dreams (This one is a toss up. I like them both but I'm also sick of both of them.

Landslide vs. Gold Dust Woman (I could happily go the rest of my life without ever hearing Landslide again)

Crystal vs. I Don't Want to Know (Hmm... let me think Lindsey doing lead vocal or a Stevie/Lindsey duet, which will I choose? )

Monday Morning vs. Second Hand News (I can't decide - I love them both!)

Blue Letter vs. Never Going Back Again

I'm So Afraid vs. Go Your Own Way (I HATE THIS VERSION OF ISA!! but it rocks live! )

Sugar Daddy vs. Oh Daddy

Warm Ways vs. Songbird

Say You Love Me vs. Don't Stop

Over My Head vs. You Make Loving Fun

World Turning vs. The Chain


White Album- 2
Rumours- 7
and two ties

[nickslover2071]

Rhiannon vs. Dreams

Landslide vs. Gold Dust Woman

Crystal vs. I Don't Want to Know

Monday Morning vs. Second Hand News

Blue Letter vs. Never Going Back Again

I'm So Afraidvs. Go Your Own Way

Sugar Daddy vs. Oh Daddy

Warm Ways vs. Songbird

Say You Love Me vs. Don't Stop

Over My Head vs. You Make Loving Fun

World Turning vs. The Chain

White Album=6
Rumours=5

[Ghosty]

I did one of these on the Stevie list. I do it different though because I can't compare well one song to another, especially if I love both the songs. So here's my silly way, I give points for each song:

0 = hate it
1 = dislike
2 = dont' care either way
3 = like
4 = love
5 = love, *LOVE* it!


White Album:
Monday Morning - 4
Warm Ways - 3
Blue Letter - 5
Rhiannon - 5
Over My Head -3
Crystal - 4
Say You Love Me - 5
Landslide - 4 (I am sick of this song, but in the past loved it, so I'll go with that to be fair)
World Turning - 2
Sugar Daddy - 3
I'm So Afraid - 3

Rumours:
Second Hand News - 5
Dreams - 5
Never Going Back Again - 5
Don't Stop -3
Go Your Own Way - 5
Songbird - 4
The Chain - 5
You Make Loving Fun - 4
I Don't Want To Know - 4
Oh Daddy - 3
Gold Dust Woman - 5


White Album - 41 points
Rumours - 48 points