The AMERICAN IDOL Thread.

[Sorceress]

Do you guys agree that Paula is on something? She seems so out of it that I'm embarrassed for her.

[WildInTheWind]

Originally Posted by ontheEdgeof17

As long as it is not Scott.........who WILL be going home tomorrow!

I'd like to see Vonzell get at least top 3. She's the only one that has gotten better week by week. By the finale, she will be smokin'!

I don't think Vonzell will win...but I hope she stays for a long time, too. She is a damn good singer. I think her performance tonight will make alot of people realize that if they haven't already.

[WildInTheWind]

Originally Posted by Sorceress

Do you guys agree that Paula is on something? She seems so out of it that I'm embarrassed for her.

Yea...she is totally not all there. She has been extra nice to everybody, too. I don't think she said a bad word about anyone tonight. But yes, she's just not right lately.

[amber]

Originally Posted by WildInTheWind

Yea...she is totally not all there. She has been extra nice to everybody, too. I don't think she said a bad word about anyone tonight. But yes, she's just not right lately.

Her eyes are a little drifty-woozy.
oh, p.s.? Anwarzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz........

[dissention]

So, I actually braved the waters and watched it tonight...

How can anyone like ANY of the male singers? Talk about atrocious. Constantine had me praying that I would go deaf and blind. That hair looked like roadkill.

I so want to get my mitts on that Scott dude and attack the sides of his face with a Lady Bic. And that shirt! You're husky, Scott, don't wear diagonal stripes. He looked like he could eat Ryan Seacrest for a minute there at the end.

The only one that's remotely talented, IMO, was the last one. I'd never listen to her CD, but she's got killer pipes (even if she was straining).

[amber]

Nadia did well, and I love that song, but it seems like she could've done a bit better, a little more dynamic vocal for that one.... I sure like her scratchy little rock voice, though (suprise! )

[dissention]

Originally Posted by Sorceress

Do you guys agree that Paula is on something? She seems so out of it that I'm embarrassed for her.

There's no question that she's abusing painkillers. No wonder she hit someone with her car and drove off. Crazy beeyotch.

[amber]

Originally Posted by dissention

So, I actually braved the waters and watched it tonight...

How can anyone like ANY of the male singers? Talk about atrocious. Constantine had me praying that I would go deaf and blind. That hair looked like roadkill.

I so want to get my mitts on that Scott dude and attack the sides of his face with a Lady Bic. And that shirt! You're husky, Scott, don't wear diagonal stripes. He looked like he could eat Ryan Seacrest for a minute there at the end.

The only one that's remotely talented, IMO, was the last one. I'd never listen to her CD, but she's got killer pipes (even if she was straining).

I don't care for the male performers much, either....

[dissention]

Originally Posted by amber

Nadia did well, and I love that song, but it seems like she could've done a bit better, a little more dynamic vocal for that one.... I sure like her scratchy little rock voice, though (suprise! )

Is she the one that sang Etheridge? Nope, thought she sucked major ass.

Talk about karaoke, sheesh. Unlike Simon, I wouldn't have shut off the microphone at the karaoke bar, I would have screamed "FIRE!"

[dissention]

Originally Posted by amber

I don't care for the male performers much, either....

They're terrible, I don't know how you guys can deal with them on a weekly basis. I find it comical when they try to hit those high notes, though. Talk about entertainment!

[amber]

Originally Posted by dissention

Is she the one that sang Etheridge? Nope, thought she sucked major ass.

Talk about karaoke, sheesh. Unlike Simon, I wouldn't have shut off the microphone at the karaoke bar, I would have screamed "FIRE!"

yeah, that was her. Oh, suprise, you thought she sucked ass? you're kidding?! Wow, you usually have such high praise for everyone....

[dissention]

Originally Posted by amber

yeah, that was her. Oh, suprise, you thought she sucked ass? you're kidding?! Wow, you usually have such high praise for everyone....

I only have high praise for that last girl. She's got a great range and anyone who can do justice to a Whitney song is a damn fine singer.

[amber]

Originally Posted by dissention

I only have high praise for that last girl. She's got a great range and anyone who can do justice to a Whitney song is a damn fine singer.

Anyone who chooses a Whitney song sucks ass, automatically. I like Nadia, she avoids the "cheesy ballad" route continuously, she rocks, and her voice is scratchy. Plus, I love her hair, and she always has the best clothes. But, you don't watch anyway, so.... I haven't heard "last girl" yet, so I don't know who you are talking about. Right this moment black guy with glasses is boring the **** out of me...

[amber]

Omigosh, Anthony was slightly less boring tonight...

[dissention]

Originally Posted by amber

Anyone who chooses a Whitney song sucks ass, automatically. I like Nadia, she avoids the "cheesy ballad" route continuously, she rocks, and her voice is scratchy. Plus, I love her hair, and she always has the best clothes. But, you don't watch anyway, so.... I haven't heard "last girl" yet, so I don't know who you are talking about. Right this moment black guy with glasses is boring the **** out of me...

Well, you can't get any more cliched once you choose a Whitney song or a Stevie Wonder song, but the same Etheridge song has been done so many times that it's just as cliched. The only one I've ever seen in the history of American Idol who chose a nice, unpredictable and eclectic mix of songs was Nikki McKibbin, and she wasn't even that good of a singer. Nikki was a cute little rocker, her voice was pretty weak, but she was certainly original.

The last girl that I'm talking about had some weird name, but I can't remember it.