Classic Album Face Off

[trackaghost]

Years ago I did a band Face Off on The Ledge that took a year (a whole year!!) to complete and in the end Led Zeppelin won. Well, in the spirit of that, here's a random Classic Albums Face Off. Just vote for the one you like the best and post which album you voted for and why. It will be fun!

[daniellaaarisen]

Hmmm limited choices..... and definitely a difficult choice at that. But I went with Bobby.

[jannieC]

Absolutely The Beatles.

Reasons: this album was made during my favorite Beatle era- moving away from Beatlemania. The music continued to improve from here on out. Getting Better, Being for the Benefiit of Mr. Kite, and A Day in the Life are my favorites.

[FMlex]

I actually went with the Beach Boys on this one.
After all, Paul McCartney did say that Pet Sounds was a major influence for Sgt. Pep.

However, all three albums were very innovative and influential.

[ILoveFM]

I voted for Sgt.Peppers! It has to be one of my favorite Beatles albums of all time. If not my favorite, it's tied with Rubber Soul. I also just saw Sir Paul (3rd row!) in Atlanta and he preformed Sgt. Peppers and it was fantastic!

[CreepingDeath]

Ah, I remember the last time you did this. Good times.


I voted for Sgt. Pepper's (although, Revolver is probably my favorite Beatles album). I've never been a big Bob Dylan fan, and the Beach Boys have always just annoyed me.

[LukeA]

Sgt. Pepper is so wildly overrated, its ridiculous.

Pet Sounds is pretty overrated too, but since its the best of these three, it gets my vote.

[bretonbanquet]

I went with the Beatles, even though Sgt Pepper might be my least favourite album of theirs... idk why, it just seems to get the least airplay. Maybe I overdid it a few years ago The other two are still awesome though

[rubytuesday]

It's getting better all the time!

I don't get bob dylan. His voice is so annoying and his style is so hard to listen to its hardly catchy. I get that some like him but I don't get how he's so legendary when he's so hard to listen to.

[mylittledemon]

For me, it was Beatles VS. Beach Boys in that round. It was a tough pick, but I have to go with Beatles because it was just such a wacky album.

[iamnotafraid]

BOB DYLAN for sure

[Dodfather]

Had to go with Sgt. Pepper here, even though I think Rubber Soul and Abbey Road are their best albums.

I wish I was on The Ledge when the year long face-off was happening..I love things like that!! Any chance of this running that long if we expand the choices? I'm up for adding a few to it to get us started...

[Musicman408]

I don't know- I went with the Beach Boys. I just DO NOT like The Beatles.

[carrie721]

for me, it was a toss up between pet sounds and highway 61 revisited. i have never been a big beatles fan and i probably never will be, although i do have an appreciation for their vast contribution to modern music and for the many bands i love that they have influenced.

pet sounds is gorgeous and fun and brilliant, but at this point in my life i prefer the nasally ramblin' man aesthetic and gritty poetry of the baaahb.

[carrie721]

also sharon i would love it if you did a big album face-off like you did a couple years ago. i joined right at the tail end of that and didn't get to participate in the whole thing. do it for me, sharon!