In the Meantime Say You Will

[chiliD]

Originally Posted by David

The artistic problem with that one was that Todd just went on & on with his guitar, & the tracks lost their shape & concision. The solos were all interchangeable, too. You could lift the solo from "I'm the One" & drop it into "One in a Million," or take the "Keeping Secrets" & drop it into "The Challenge," & essentially you'd be left with the same track & the same atmosphere & texture..

No..."The Challenge" was different. That wasn't Todd, that was Eric Clapton, so right there, that deflates your "interchangable" theory. You can't "interchange" a Clapton solo.

[Gailh]

Originally Posted by macfan 57

I like your list, Gail...although I'd replace "Silver Girl" with maybe "Smile At You". I'd still like to put "Forgiveness" somewhere on that CD. Don't worry about those guitar solos. Remember, a certain someone mentioned that there was too much guitar on SYW.

I've listened to it and I think I'd replace Red Rover with Miranda.

I wanted to get Forgiveness in but I couldn't make it fit anywhere.

I could be more flexible with Chris' songs as as like nearly all of them. My choice of Stevie and Lindsey songs was limited.

Gail

[macfan 57]

Originally Posted by Gailh

I've listened to it and I think I'd replace Red Rover with Miranda.

I wanted to get Forgiveness in but I couldn't make it fit anywhere.

I could be more flexible with Chris' songs as as like nearly all of them. My choice of Stevie and Lindsey songs was limited.

Gail

I could see why it would be easier to fit in the Christine songs on the CD... too many good songs. One of these days, I'm finally going to burn a ITM/SYW CD myself. By the way, I wasn't critisizing your track list. It's a good one.

[DestinyRules]

Originally Posted by Gailh

8. Silver Girl (I LIKE IT)
Gail

"Silver Girl" is absolutely horrendous. Replace it with "Destiny Rules" and we'll talk.

Here's my pick for a combined album:

1. Miranda
2. Friend
3. Running Through The Garden
4. You Are
5. What's The World Coming To
6. Thrown Down
7. Liar
8. Smile At You
9. Steal Your Heart Away
10. Givin' It Back
11. Everybody Finds Out
12. Calumny
13. Destiny Rules
14. Murrow Turning Over In His Grave

No "Come," No "Bad Journey," No Silver Hurl.

[Gailh]

Originally Posted by DestinyRules

"Silver Girl" is absolutely horrendous. Replace it with "Destiny Rules" and we'll talk.

Here's my pick for a combined album:

1. Miranda
2. Friend
3. Running Through The Garden
4. You Are
5. What's The World Coming To
6. Thrown Down
7. Liar
8. Smile At You
9. Steal Your Heart Away
10. Givin' It Back
11. Everybody Finds Out
12. Calumny
13. Destiny Rules
14. Murrow Turning Over In His Grave

No "Come," No "Bad Journey," No Silver Hurl.

Your track listing has merits I have to admit but I like Silver Girl (I may of course be in need of therapy or some sort of counselling or it maybe too late)

Good job we're not all the same isn't it?

Five Christine songs out of 14 - nice proportion

Gail