Quote:
Originally Posted by TrueFaith77
[ Ryan provides the context for the next shot: Her group in the Kodak lobby, with Tatiana overwhelmed with emotion and gratitude. Tatiana thanks "Jesus" and "God" and "the guy holding the sound stick" and everyone involved in the show. It's beautiful. Then she really lets loose -- and it is awesomely audacious: "You all make this part of me. You are all part of me. I will take each and every one of you in my heart for the rest of my life." American Idol attempts to pervert as vanity this display of profound humility -- one expressed in an impromptu dramatic flourish! Imagine her now-famous laugh: articulated.
|
Are you serious? OK. I might agree if she had also thanked the members of her group.
Quote:
Originally Posted by TrueFaith77
I'm actually glad Rose is gone. I didn't like anything she sang, but "Don't Stop" was the final straw... even Alex Wagner-Trugman pulling faces during "Don't Stop" made me mad at him. And he's been my second favorite contestant.
|
Rose didn't sing Don't Stop.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HejiraNYC
As opposed to Stevie's more recent massacres of that song?  Technically she would have been booted off of AI for not singing the correct lyrics.
But yes, it was terrible last night. |
It's one thing to change it up a bit like La Nicks; it's quite another to completely forget you rlines & start humming or shove a "ooooh" or a "lalala" in there instead.
Not that I'm a big fan of Stevie's versions...