I am a 9.5-10 and I wear Converse/Chuck Taylor's the majority of the time. My current faves are turqouise with hot pink insides. I always try to get a whole bunch in different colors but I usually get lazy and the most I've ever had at once is three (purple, green, turqouise).
I also love my
Toms Shoes. They are pretty much basic slip ons, but they are ridiculously comfortable. I have a few pairs but my favorite are the brown corduroy ones. Also, whenever you buy a pair, it means a pair of shoes is automatically donated to a child in need. Really a great and comfy cause!