[gldstwmn]

Originally Posted by strandinthewind

I think the point is his best was inadequate in that case of SYW. He had done brilliant things with the same kind of demos before and did not on SYW. I think his fans are loathe to admit that because somehow it seemingly lessens him. Everyone fails and he did in the eyes of most (that I've heard tell) in the case of SYW. His songs were great, and should have been after working on them so long. Who knows -- maybe if he had had more time, his work on La Nicks' demos would have been better. But, he had about two years and had heard a few of them before. And, some came in a more fleshed out form than just her on a piano. Actually, the No Light demo (GB) was, I believe, just that - her on a piano -- and that IMO is the best song on SYW.

In the end, I wish they would collaborate instead of doing whatever they did on SYW.

You're confusing No Light and The Tower.