No, its not that I personally hate it, its just my least favorite on SYW. Its not because of the lyrics, its because of the melody, it just makes me not like it as much as say-RTTG [oh do you have the demo Ethan, it is amazing!], Thrown Down, or even Smile At You [again, I like the angry demo better than here, but I still like it on SYW].
One of my petpeevs about Everybody Finds Out, is that Linds sings in the chorus, the 'i know he loves me....'etc. Its just it makes him sound...colorful in words....

she should have just sang it alone, and on SYHA she shouldnt have sang. but i still Love both of those songs
