Quote:
|
Originally Posted by amber
That's what I was talking about!
Now it has "potential...for a silly production", but when I said it did, it was assinine.
Got it.
|
No, you originally said:
I love those books, which is why I don't want to see a movie version. You know, all christianity aside?
I then replied:
Well, that is assinine. The LOTR movies were good if not great adaptations of Tolkein's great works and pretty much all movies come from books. So, are you saying no book should ever be made into a movie?
To which you then replied (comment supplied) :
Yep. [presumbaly in response to the last question] Oh, and I don't like LOTR. Not that that makes it bad, of course. I don't want to see people act out those parts, and everything else. I can't envision them doing such a good job that I will like the movie. It's possible, and I hope they do, but I really doubt it. I'm so glad you included the word "assinine" in that post, too. That was extra special.
_____________________________
Thus, my assinine comment was to your first statement which in no way qualified the silly production angle you later took on.