Quote:
|
Originally Posted by skcin
Smart ass.  I caught it hours after I typed it, too lazy to edit.
Why is it inconsistent? My opinion is that I am moved more by live versions of ISA - the guitar is more emotional to me. I don't know how to put it into words. Rhiannon - the vocal is much more raw live, blows me away, I love it.
Are you saying that I should vote off Rhiannon cuz I like it better live? My answer to that is I prefer album Rhiannon over album ISA. Kay? 
That being said, I vote off Blue Letter cuz I prefer it live. 
JK about the live thing - but I am voting off Blue Letter. |
What I meant is: Why voting off a song because it's better live? The live versions are not on the album, the studioversions are. So I'd say: keep the arguments inside the album. I am ticky about it because that live version argument is used for voting off ISA, and not for f.i. Rhiannon.
I agree that both songs are better live, but that is saying NOTHING about the quality of the studiotracks.
So my vote for RHIANNON was meant as a cynical vote, because I felt that ISA was leaving this round, and I was right. Amazing because it is one of the most excentric and spheric tracks on the album. It deserves better.
so because I was right in the fact that ISA was going in round three for unfair reasons, this is my protestvote again
ROUND 4: RHIANNON, because it's better live.
