I love both albums. I think Chris' songs on The Dance were better selected(Everywhere, a better SYLM, YMLF). Lindsey's stuff is 10 times better on '80. The NGBA is my favorite version of that song. And call me a freak, but I love Not That Funny live. The only song better on The Dance is ISA.
As for Stevie, it's a toss up. I love Sara, Fireflies, and Rhiannon from '80. Landslide is excellent on both. Her fragile voice on '80 brings a tear to my eye (Fragile as in hoarse
). SS is of course a highlight from The Dance. Dreams.....both good versions.
If I had to bring one with me to a deserted island....I would take '80....