First on my list would have to be Marty and/or Liz. Why? Duh...
I, too, would have to add Christy (wondergirl) for both enthusiasm and just being an all around nice person.
Then John (wetcamelfood), a real fan, and a real nice guy. And since he doesn't collect bootlegs, he deserves to have something really cool!
Last I'd have to go with Brian (estranged4life) again true fan and someone who keeps the music a flowin'...
But GOD there are so many others...like Neil (nodmod), Les, Johnny Stew, Livia, chiliD, David...
And thanks David! I'm flattered that I even made your "runners-up" list...