wow, what an extensive list...but good topic/thread. Wild Hearted, I pretty much cut/paste alot of your answers. Is it any wonder why almost ALL of Tusk is Perfect?
Fleetwood Mac:
Perfection: Rhiannon, Crystal, Say You Love Me, World Turning
Like: Blue Letter, I'm So Afraid, MM, Sugar Daddy, OMH
Neutral/cheesy: Landslide, Warm Ways
Rumours
Perfection: Dreams, Go Your Own Way, The Chain, You Make Loving Fun, Gold Dust Woman
Like: I Don't Want to Know, Second Hand News
Cheesy: Never Going Back Again, Don't Stop, Songbird, Oh Daddy (like the live version much better)
Tusk
Perfection: Over and Over, The Ledge, Think About Me, Sara, What Makes You Think You're The One, Storms, Not That Funny, Sisters of the Moon, Beautiful Child, I Know I'm Not Wrong, Never Forget, Tusk, Angel, Brown Eyes
Like: Honey Hi, That's Enough For Me
Neutral: Never Make Me Cry
Dislike: Save Me a Place, Walk a Thin Line, That's All For Everyone
Live:
Perfection: Fireflies, Farmers Daughter
Like: DLMDA, Oh Well
Neutral: One More Night
Mirage
Perfection: Love in Store, Can't Go Back, That's Alright, Gypsy, Hold Me, Oh Diane
Like: Straight Back, Eyes of the World, Wish You Were Here, Book of Love, Empire State
Neutral/ Cheesy: Only Over You
Tango in the Night
Perfection: Big Love, Tango in the Night, Little Lies, Isn't it Midnight
Like: Seven Wonders, Everywhere, Caroline, Family Man, When I See You Again
Neutral: Welcome to the Room... Sara, You and I Part II
Cheesy: Mystified
The Dance
Perfection: My Little Demon, Sweet Girl, Silver Springs
Like: Bleed to Love Her
Neutral: Temporary One