It's hard to compare the different line-ups. Rumours topping the B&N-era list makes sense, but Then Play On is my favorite of the PG-era so I would've put it above Fleetwood Mac 1968. I also can't get into Tango in the Night, I think it's too overproduced. I like Kiln House better than Mirage as well.
The songs in the song list are quality, but I would have a hard time ranking them across the different line-ups. I love "Green Manalishi" and "Station Man" and "Homeward Bound" for example, more than I like "Over My Head". But "Over My Head" is a deserving hit of the B&N era, so.
|