Really hate Silver Girl, hate Goodbye Baby almost as much. I love both RTTG and EFO, and think Thrown Down is terrific. I think it's best to look at SYW Smile At You as essentially a different song from the old demos - saves the trouble of complaining about changes when both recordings are, independently, very good songs. Illume does go on for far too long, but it's at least musically more interesting than usual.
|