Silver Girl
 

I am really tired of people bashing this song... this is one of the highlights of the cd... every bit as entrancing as " mystified" was on Tango .. and " over and over" on Tusk...
I really love it....great production and so soothing to listen to..
I also love " Not make Beleive" .. especially lindsey's subtle guitar work on it... pure magic...
no matter how you slice it .. this album is a triumph ... a victory for FM as a whole..... a definite victory for stevie and lindsey's relationship..... superb musicianship... and very innovative production.....its like this is what FM would have sounded like if the whole band lived with lindsey in his basement :)
I never thought I'd ever hear Stevie's voice sound this strong and passionate again.... what a great victory for her.... to defeat the deamons of addiction and botched relationships and other pitfalls .....and still come out sounding like the beautiful angel she was when she joined FM...
I hope this isnt the last album from them... love to hear more of this saga :)

PS
 

Kudos to John Mc Vie here as well.... great work on all the bass parts... it doesnt go un noticed..:)

You're not alone
 

Well the band put the song on the album for a reason. I guess they liked it. :)

I enjoy the song too. It has a different sound than anything else on the record. And like you say it does have that soothing appeal to it. Actually I like to listen to it just for Stevie's vocal and the melody. There are other tracks on the cd that I listen to less, for sure. So I'm with you rhianntp.


Joe

I agree also....I dig the song....and the album as a whole....

Not Make Believe is every bit as good as " you and I part II"

in fact i prefer it :)

See I don't like Mystified either. Silver Girl is the song I skip usually, I just don't like it. I guess if I didn't know what it was about Id be ok with it.

But the line " she has a million bucks and she looks like it"...just don't sit well with me.

Im not bashing it, but if I HAD to choose my least favorite song on the album, this would be it probably.

I don't think it's an awful song, but I think it stands out on the album as one of its weaker tracks. I think it could have been better, and that's what turns me off about it.

I like it and the way it's written. When I listen to it, it seems to me that Stevie was trying to paint a vivid picture of this human character. She explains how the "silver girl" is a wild one, a girl who has made good things happen for herself in such a hard world, how she is much wiser than her years let on, how she is very guarded and doesn't trust people easily, how she wishes she had been born earlier in life, and how with all the things she has (a million bucks and good looks), she still wants things from life that will make her happy; the money and how she looks are just superficial things to her.

That's what I took away from the song! :)

Now..."Not Make Believe" is just awful. How bad are the lyrics? So cliched and unimaginative and uncreative. It's just bad. "It hurts my self-esteem/It hurts my everything." Blech. It's just terrible and a shame that it was even released without being tweaked with a LOT more. I think it stands as one of the worst FM songs committed to record. :eek:

I like it, but my one criticism is the '90s production sound. I imagine the demo with just piano or guitar is simpler and better (don't hit me). I'm surprised that some posters said they think it needs a bigger production.

- Jake

I like this song. Better than "Destiny Rules" and "Illume."

Silver Girl
 

I honestly don't have a lot to add to the content of this thread but I know that some people don't like this song because Stevie has said that she wrote it about Sheryl Crow. I think that tidbit should be overlooked and think of Stevie and her life while listening to it. It is about her basically. I like the song a lot, I love her voice and the sound of it of the production. I like how it wasn't overdone IMO.

I don't like it.. but I like it better than Illume.

I really like this song. It goes with the introspective mood I am in right now. I like the production and everything.
If there was a weak Stevie track, I would have to go with 'Say You Will.' It is just not as powerful as the other songs. It's a good song, but it doesn't make me THINK like the other songs do...

Randy

whats the big deal if she wrote it about sheryl crow?... she knows sheryl better than any of you do i bet... perhaps sheryl is more of a sister of the moon than we all realise..

This song ain't great..... I would have rather heard "The Dealer".........

It seems like SYW was willing to pull old stuff back from the graveyard......