The Ledge - Crash oct. vs. Crash feb.

Alright. I LOVE the version of crash from Roseont. The song seemed to have an atmosphere about it, AND Shes actually FEELING the song, shes swaying along, fliping her hair,moving her body, and gennerally convaying a sincere love for it.
FAST FORWARD A COUPPLE MONTHS TO FEB.
I HATE the version someone filmed. AND I NEVER SAY THAT ABOUT STEVIE. But it seems contrived, "part of the routine", stale, AND ALSO MOST ANNOYING, the music seems to have lost the drums and strings effect from rosemont, to JUST carllos strumming away. Im glad we get the "before it became part of the show" version for soundstage.

DO THESE VERSIONS SEEM TOTALLY DIFFERENT TO ANNYONE ELSE?
Pant suitSpoken barked vocals, skirt hiking replaced w/hand wobling.

V.S>

Flowy dress,More movement,skirt hiking,Better music sung with Feeling:

Whadda ya think? remember, not SOUND QUALITY, but preformance.