I love thick, creamy
 

Peanutbutter. Who doesn't?

I don't get how people like the chunky kind. The extra peanuts kind of weird me out.

I only eat Jif. Creamy.

...with lots of grape jelly! :wavey:

YUM!!! Grape or Strawberry..I can go either way....:D

:nod:

I'm totally bi when it comes to jelly. I love mixed fruit, too.

I only like crunchy. And I have never eaten a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. The two together freak me out. :cool:

ditto, somehow the two of them together doesn't sound aesthetically pleasing to me.

Ew, I know. Eating it as a kid always made me feel like I was doing something wrong... :laugh:

I love pb with almost any kind of jam, except for the weird combos like apricot or grape. Strawberry is the way to go!

You should try Skippy light. It's the only kind I'll eat.

Have you tried the honey-roasted Skippy? So. freaking. good. Sometimes I'll just get a big spoonful and eat it right out of the jar. :laugh:

Hmm..I don't know - I'm not very open-minded in the food department, and I've never really taken to regular Skippy or Peter Pan..Jif is where it's at.

Buuuut....I have a problem with Jif. It's only great for so long - a few days or so after it's been opened it tastes like every other peanut butter :shrug:

I used to love Apricot jelly - but as of late I can only do Grape or Strawberry - and I need them to be low-sugar or I just can't handle 'em.

Oh and I was 25 years old when I finally had my first fluffernutter :p

So with mixed jelly...you're actually TRI! groan. That's bad...but your mention of jelly threw me over the edge I am really craving a peanut butter and jelly sandwich now :laugh:

Dude, no! I didn't even know such a thing existed. That sounds divine. *mouth waters*

Regular Skippy is kind of heavy, I find. But the light is really good. There's a huge difference in texture and everything. I only go for half or no sugar jam, too. I've found I can't take sicky sweet things anymore. :shrug:

I've never had fluffernutter at all. Can I blame it on being Canadian? :cool:

Sure! Or you can blame it on not wanting to go into extreme diabetic shock :laugh: I was not a fan of the fluffernutter.

Hmm...I'm reluctant to try a new peanut butter :o Perhaps one day - I buy it so infrequently...it's not one of my staples.

Ew - this reminds me - on the Today Show yesterday they were profiling this new "automat" style restaurant in New York -and one of their offerings was a FRIED Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich....the sight of it made me gag...