Changes in faves on SYW?
 

I was thinking about how my opinions have changed a lil on my faves on SYW.

This is the list I made back on 4-17-2003.

1. RED ROVER
2. Come
3. Peacekeeper
4. Everybody Finds Out
5. Smile at You
6. Murrow
7. Bleed to Love Her
8. Steal Your Heart Away
9. Destiny Rules
10. Illume
11. Thrown Down
12. WTWCT
13. RTTG
14. SYW
15. Miranda
16. Goodbye Baby
17. Say Goodbye
18. Silver Girl

Now, it's changed a bit. Here is my new listing.

1. RED ROVER (No surprise here. LOL)
2. Come (Here either)
3. Smile at You
4. Murrow
5. Destiny Rules
6. Everybody Finds Out
7. Say Goodbye (Prefer the GOS version)
8. Steal Your Heart Away
9. Illume
10. Bleed to Love Her
11. Peacekeeper (Prefer the solo version)
12. RTTG
13. Thrown Down
14. Miranda (Prefer the GOS version)
15. WTWCT
16. Goodbye Baby
17. SYW
18. Silver Girl

Upon first listen, my Top 5 were

1. Thrown Down
2. Peacekeeper
3. Miranda
4. RTTG
5. SYW

Now they're

1. Miranda
2. Thrown Down
3. Peacekeeper
4. Everybody Finds Out
5. Smile At You

I don't have the list I compiled last year, but a few songs have really grown on me since then...

My current rankings:

1. Destiny Rules
2. Running Through The Garden
3. Peackeeper (I still love this song, no matter how bad it translates live)
4. Say Goodbye (Has really grown on me. I used to think it was terribly boring, but after hearing it live...)
5. Miranda
6. Say You Will
7. Come
8. What's The World Coming To
9. Everybody Finds Out (Sorry, it still sounds funky to me. I wont deny that its a good song tho)
10. Thrown Down (Used to be my #1. I must have listened to it too many times :p )
11. Steal Your Heart Away
12. Murrow
13. Silver Girl
14. Bleed To Love Her
15. Smile At You
16. Goodbye Baby
17. Red Rover
18. Illume (I hate this song)

I still only like the same three songs that I liked on it when I first heard it.

Which ones are those songs, Eric?

Well... I remember that my favorite was "Say Goodbye". It still is, for sure. I think the lyrical/musical complementation is nonparleil. I was quite fond of "Say You Will" but after 1,000 listens it kind of bores you doesn't it. As I recall I wasn't a huge supporter of "Red Rover" at first but now it's one of my favorites; and it happened vice-versa with "Murrow" (yeah, those effects are nice for awhile, but it gets a little bit tiring). I still HATE "Silver Girl" with all my soul and passion; and don't have affection to the studio version of "Come", either.

My list now should look something like this:

1. Say Goodbye
2. Red Rover
3. Steal Your Heart Away
4. Thrown Down
5. Running Through The Garden
6. Destiny Rules
7. Say You Will
8. Everybody Finds Out
9. Smile At You (had they released the 'angry' version of this, it would be #1)
10. Goodbye Baby (I remember I liked this one more the first times... I know it's great but...)
11. Peacekeeper
12. Miranda
13. Bleed To Love Her (I love this song... in the Dance version)
14. What's The World Coming To
15. Illume 9-11
16. Murrow Turning Over In His Grave
17. Come
18. Silver Girl


Song of the moment - Brown Eyes

reply
 

Personally I have fell in Love with Goodbye Baby and Whats the World Coming to. Murrow has also came to my liking.

Come has always bored me, live and on the record. Well live on the guitar solo is different. But alot of the LIndsey stalkers like it because when he points to them and all that crap. But if he never put the killer guitar solo on the end of the song it would suck.

I like Murrow because od the chourus. I love that murrow turnin over in his grave part.

SYW- still I like it.

Songs I skip:
Illume
Red Rover(hate this--cannot stand it)
Peacekeeper
Come
Destiny Rules
Say Goodbye(better live)

I like the track listing ok, but I would've kept the album shorter.

1) Whats the World Coming To
2) Murrow Turning over in His Grave
3) Thrown Down
4) Say you Will
5) Peacekeeper
6) Come
7) Running Thru the Garden
8) Silver Girl
9) Steal Your Heart Away
10) Bleed 2 Love Her
11) Destiny Rules
12) Say Goodbye

BRANDoN

Can someone please give me a good reason why they don't like illume? It is one of my favorites on the album...

I can't stand this song. Those freaky voices in the middle, for one thing, and for some reason the percussion bugs me.

My favorites then are still my favorites now: Thrown Down, Say Goodbye, Steal Your Heart Away, Running Through the Garden, and Goodbye Baby.

Peacekeeper and Say you Will are up there too.

Murrow, Come, and Red Rover have grown on me quite a bit.

I hate Illume.

The rest are ok.

Sorry. lol

Those three I like are Miranda, Peacekeeper, and Say You Will.

Miranda never did anything for me, GOS or SYW, but now it's slowly but surely climbed into my top 10.

Which I guess would be (in no particular order)

Murrow
Miranda
Illume
TD
RTTG
DR
RR
Peacekeeper
Come (loved it the first time I heard the GOS demos)
SG


Goodbye Baby - I've been spoilt by the blissful live arrangement I've heard in bootlegs.

change peacekeeper in WTWCT and you got more or less my list, too!!

I guess nothing has really changed in my appreciation towards the SYW songs except that:

I've learned to like "Peacekeeper" and ignore the annoying modernistic programmed drum break.

I've learned to like "Silver Girl".

I've learned to like "Steal Your Heart Away".

Note: "SYHA" improved in my mind because of certain substances. ;)

Are these the same substances that made you like Silver girl? :laugh: