The Ledge

The Ledge (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/index.php)
-   Rumours (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Tusk Album 1 vs. Album 2 (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/showthread.php?t=55278)

WildHeart97 06-03-2015 06:14 PM

Tusk Album 1 vs. Album 2
 
Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

WildHeart97 06-03-2015 06:46 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Montclare 06-03-2015 09:35 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me (near impossible pick as both are two of my favorite FM songs. Catch me on a different day and I might go with TL.)
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

On Ice 06-03-2015 09:39 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes (Do I really have to choose, total tie)
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

jbrownsjr 06-04-2015 08:30 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

SisterNightroad 06-04-2015 09:19 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

vivfox 06-04-2015 09:58 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

I didn't like pitting SOTM against Never Forget.

louielouie2000 06-04-2015 11:13 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

lilyfee 06-04-2015 12:16 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

ViscountViktor 06-04-2015 12:23 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel - too hard, I love both!
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Straightback 06-04-2015 12:46 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

FuzzyPlum 06-04-2015 01:06 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget tie

I think I might have done this before at some point. I'll feel really stupid when I find out I put half of them the other way around last time.

Vanessa 06-04-2015 02:34 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Dreamz19 06-04-2015 03:38 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line (Hardest choice yet. These are 2 of my favorite songs on the album.)
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Neal 06-04-2015 08:50 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Side 1 - 6 / Side 2 - 5

sorcerer999 06-04-2015 09:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by louielouie2000 (Post 1167351)
Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

^^^ Same!

Sorry to piggyback off your post, Louie, but I'm in a lazy mood tonight and I agree with ALL your choices. :lol:

ryan4136 06-05-2015 07:31 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

jcalzaretta 06-05-2015 09:36 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel Tough call
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong THIS IS WRONG TO HAVE THESE TWO TOGETHER. IKINW IS AMAZING. SARA IS DOWNRIGHT BRILLIANT
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child SO UNFAIR
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

elle 06-05-2015 08:07 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Keith 06-06-2015 06:49 AM

Listening to vinyl Tusk as I write...
 
Over & Over vs. Angel - Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me - The Ledge
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes - Think About Me
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry - Save Me a Place (fave track by Lindsey on Tusk)
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong - Sara (fave Tusk track) love, love I Know I'm Not Wrong... glad it is still in the setlist.
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi - Honey Hi (those harmonies)
Storms vs. Beautiful Child - hmmm. this one is tough because I love both for such different reasons. Another coin toss.. Beautiful Child.
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line - Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk - Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget - Never Forget - a beautiful closer to this quirky, all over the place, imperfect, but gorgeous record.
Reply With Quote

tz5632 06-10-2015 06:46 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

aleuzzi 06-10-2015 11:36 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

jbrownsjr 06-10-2015 12:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aleuzzi (Post 1167965)
Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Angel vs Over and Over ... very difficult for me to choose...

KenB 06-10-2015 12:41 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong Neither, dislike both
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

welcomechris 06-10-2015 05:37 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Frankenstein 06-10-2015 11:59 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

He's So Unusual 06-15-2015 01:36 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

AncientQueen 06-15-2015 05:15 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child WHOA, both are not for me
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

That was much harder then I expected.

bangdrum 06-16-2015 06:22 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me - both
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

GypsySorcerer 06-16-2015 09:17 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel (Just barely)
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes (I love Think About Me, though.)
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child (Tough one)
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Seasonsofmylife 06-17-2015 03:24 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child --> This one was quite though, I love both songs for different reasons.
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

76sparky 06-18-2015 06:28 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Couldn't pick between Storms and Beautiful child

Tango 06-18-2015 09:27 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes (neither)
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong (but love IKINW on tour)
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi (neither)
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Dr.Brown 06-19-2015 08:30 AM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes - Pitting Christine against herself is so unfair but haunting harmonies plus Peter Green's backing guitar at the end give BE the edge.
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong - No contest. The song which made me fall in love with FM and still my favorite. Fantastic production and work on the part of everyone in the band.
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child - Both among Stevie's best though.
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk - Somehow the song Tusk never appealed to me - too disjointed perhaps which is something someone might say about the album as a whole.
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget - SOTM live is so much better than the album version but Never Forget is the Perfect closer for the Tusk album.

KarmaContestant 06-19-2015 10:05 AM

Tusk is a great album, conceptually. But for me it is lacking in terms of 'strong' material. It's so mish/mash.


Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me - I love both of these.
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk - I don't particularly like either of these.
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

redbird 06-29-2015 01:31 PM

Over & Over vs. Angel
The Ledge vs. That's Enough For Me
Think About Me vs. Brown Eyes
Save Me a Place vs. Never Make Me Cry
Sara vs. I Know I'm Not Wrong
What Makes You Think You're The One vs. Honey Hi
Storms vs. Beautiful Child (!!!)
That's All For Everyone vs. Walk a Thin Line
Not That Funny vs. Tusk
Sisters of the Moon vs. Never Forget

Tusk 1: 5
Tusk 2: 5

Sounds about right :)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:04 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
© 1995-2003 Martin and Lisa Adelson, All Rights Reserved