The Ledge

The Ledge (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/index.php)
-   Rumours (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   So If Christine, Stevie and Lindsey were to bring in one existing solo song.. (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/showthread.php?t=53144)

FMM2 01-15-2014 01:22 AM

So If Christine, Stevie and Lindsey were to bring in one existing solo song..
 
from their existing solo libraries for a new album. Which songs would you choose?

For Stevie, "AnnaLee" - that song sounds more Fleetwood Mac than much of Say You Will and would rock as an FM song!!

For Christine, I'm thinking "Friend" would be a fantastic one for her.

And Lindsey, I have always wondered what a full on Fleetwood Mac arrangement of "Trouble" would sound like!

Thoughts?

FMM2

PenguinHead 01-15-2014 03:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FMM2 (Post 1117483)
from their existing solo libraries for a new album. Which songs would you choose?

For Stevie, "AnnaLee" - that song sounds more Fleetwood Mac than much of Say You Will and would rock as an FM song!!

For Christine, I'm thinking "Friend" would be a fantastic one for her.

And Lindsey, I have always wondered what a full on Fleetwood Mac arrangement of "Trouble" would sound like!

Thoughts?

FMM2

Those are great choices.

It would be nice for Christine to perform her one big solo hit, Got A Hold On Me.

It would be really nice for Stevie to drop Stand Back, and replace it with some other upbeat song like In Your Dreams or Imperial Hotel. Implausible, I know.

KenshiMaster16 01-15-2014 03:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FMM2 (Post 1117483)
from their existing solo libraries for a new album. Which songs would you choose?

For Stevie, "AnnaLee" - that song sounds more Fleetwood Mac than much of Say You Will and would rock as an FM song!!

For Christine, I'm thinking "Friend" would be a fantastic one for her.

And Lindsey, I have always wondered what a full on Fleetwood Mac arrangement of "Trouble" would sound like!

Thoughts?

FMM2

Stevie: Planets Of The Universe. Would love to hear the Mac play this since it's been featured on the Rumours re-releases.
Christine: Agreed with Friend, would've fit in perfectly with the Mac catalogue.
Lindsey: Switch out Stevie's party anthem for Lindsey's and gimme Holiday Road. lol Now THAT would be interesting, have Mick do the grunts or barks or whatever towards the end. lol

ryan4136 01-15-2014 09:27 AM

Very good choices on all three.

I thought Friend sounded like a FM song the moment I heard it, if you added a quirky guitar part fill somewhere, and with Mic and John. Would've done well on the charts...probably still could since most don't know it.

Stevie I'd really like to hear Planets, but not if they over produce it like they did with Smile At You.

LB is a little tougher because so many of his songs don't really fit the "band" feel. That's the point I guess.
Couple choices, a more modern sounding "Soul Drifter", "Surrender the Rain", "Down on Rodeo" (but that's practically already been done as a MAC song), Love Runs Deeper.

There are others I'd selfishly like to hear, but I think those fit the "band" type of sound.

SteveMacD 01-15-2014 10:29 AM

I think the intro on "Friend" is a bit of a rip-off of YMLF.

ryan4136 01-15-2014 11:15 AM

Very much. She was channeling her inner LB, and reusing a few bars here and there.

jbrownsjr 01-15-2014 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ryan4136 (Post 1117505)
Very much. She was channeling her inner LB, and reusing a few bars here and there.

I have a friend that is not a FMac fan. He always asks me, "Has Lindsey written, 'Big Love' again yet?"

gssmith 01-15-2014 12:48 PM

I've always thought Stop Dragging my heart around would be a good replacement of Stand Back. I understand that Stevie wants a rocker to do since most of her FWM songs are slow or mid tempo. Edge of 17 wouldn't fit with the band.
For Christine I wish she would do some pre 75 songs: Why, Spare me a little, get like you used to.
I can't comment on Lindsey don't know his solo music at all. I don't think I've even heard a song. I should really check out you tube

elle 01-15-2014 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PenguinHead (Post 1117487)
It would be nice for Christine to perform her one big solo hit, Got A Hold On Me.

It would be really nice for Stevie to drop Stand Back, and replace it with some other upbeat song like In Your Dreams or Imperial Hotel. Implausible, I know.

i'm going with your understanding of this thread: what solo songs they can perform with FM.

re what solo songs that are already out as solo to put on a new FM album - why do that? don't you want to get new songs?? plus LB already brought tons of his solo songs to previous FM albums - TITN and SYW come to mind. so it's been done, and some people loved it, others hated it. ;)

it's interesting to read suggestions that seem to point out how little people here know of LB's solo catalog. (Trouble? shoot me now. :p) personally, i like it much better when people say "i don't know" instead, like gssmith did.

so going with that, since i don't know enough of SN's or CM's solo catalog i'll stay away from suggesting EO17. :p

for LB, if FM is performing a solo song from each songwriter, That's The Way Love Goes should be the one. :thumbsup:

although as LB said, Mick would love to have the opportunity to drum live on Gift of Screws, but that song may be too left field for the Mac set. TTWLG has just the right balance of popiness, rockiness and punkishness to still fit into the Mac set and rejuvenate it. (of course, my very first choice would be In Our Own Time, but that one may be too "edgy".)

Macfanforever 01-15-2014 01:15 PM

I dont see why not .Stevie has Standback..I would like to see Lindsey put Trouble in the set list.Christine can put her solo tunes in setlist and there will be no time for any covers.

elle 01-15-2014 01:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Macfanforever (Post 1117529)
I dont see why not .Stevie has Standback..I would like to see Lindsey put Trouble in the set list.Christine can put her solo tunes in setlist and there will be no time for any covers.

:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol: see the post above.

jbrownsjr 01-15-2014 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Macfanforever (Post 1117529)
I dont see why not .Stevie has Standback..I would like to see Lindsey put Trouble in the set list.Christine can put her solo tunes in setlist and there will be no time for any covers.

They actually rehearsed, "Trouble" during Mirage rehearsals.

michelej1 01-15-2014 01:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elle (Post 1117526)
although as LB said, Mick would love to have the opportunity to drum live on Gift of Screws, but that song may be too left field for the Mac set.

I'd love to see GOS, not necessarily with FM. But if they put it in I couldn't complain too much. It's so short that I don't think it would disrupt an FM show or be as incongruent as Come was. It's over before you know it.

I don't know if playing it requires something differently than his other songs do, but I've never seen Lindsey look quite like he does during that song. It almost reminds me of trying to hold a power drill and you have to concentrate with all your might, as it vibrates through you, because the force is such that if you loosen up it could knock you flat on your face.

As for Christine, for the crowd I'd choose Gotta Hold On Me and I'd love that for myself too, but I'd also love a selection from Meantime. But I actually think it would be a good thing to bring Gotta Hold back to everyone's memory. It's been forgotten and I'd love to feel that, "hey I remember that" ripple.

But I'm not actually in favor of them doing solo songs. They have enough unheard Mac songs. Stevie can keep her Stand Back and there are other things I want from Christine and Lindsey.

Michele

Macfanforever 01-15-2014 01:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elle (Post 1117530)
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol: see the post above.

Hahaha sorry . I notice that.



Quote:

Originally Posted by jbrownsjr (Post 1117539)
They actually rehearsed, "Trouble" during Mirage rehearsals.

That I did not know.

Macfanforever 01-15-2014 01:42 PM

It would be nice if all of them do a medley of hits from their solo career.Just a verse of a song .Time would be limited for that as long they sing most of their hits and some new tunes in the mix.

It would be fulfilling for a show as I seen other artists do song medleys.

michelej1 01-15-2014 01:44 PM

I really hate medleys. Just as they start to flesh something out the song ends. I find them lazy and unsatisfying. Please never cross my path, medley.

Michele

Macfanforever 01-15-2014 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by michelej1 (Post 1117550)
I really hate medleys. Just as they start to flesh something out the song ends. I find them lazy and unsatisfying. Please never cross my path, medley.

Michele

Yes .I'm probably used of hearing medleys when I go to the country concerts.
They seem to have a habit doing medleys.

lbfan 01-15-2014 02:15 PM

Solo Songs
 
Although not a solo song, I would love to see/hear them do Christine's "Why." The Midnight Special version is fantastic. For Stevie, I would love to hear "Gold & Braid." I always thought Lindsey could take that to another level (like he did with "Oh Well"). For Lindsey, I would love to have him do "Countdown." It was performed live only once (ensemble version) on David Letterman in 1992. Alternate for Stevie would be "Leather and Lace" (although some may object). For Lindsey, the song "Gift of Screws" rocks live. For Christine, I thought "I Can't Help Falling in Love" the Elvis cover she did (with Lindsey producing) would be cool to hear live.

nightbird28 01-15-2014 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ryan4136 (Post 1117498)
Very good choices on all three.

I thought Friend sounded like a FM song the moment I heard it, if you added a quirky guitar part fill somewhere, and with Mic and John. Would've done well on the charts...probably still could since most don't know it.

Stevie I'd really like to hear Planets, but not if they over produce it like they did with Smile At You.

LB is a little tougher because so many of his songs don't really fit the "band" feel. That's the point I guess.
Couple choices, a more modern sounding "Soul Drifter", "Surrender the Rain", "Down on Rodeo" (but that's practically already been done as a MAC song), Love Runs Deeper.

There are others I'd selfishly like to hear, but I think those fit the "band" type of sound.

Love Runs Deeper would be amazing!
Stevie, I'd love to hear Candlebright or perhaps Miss You.
Christine it definitely has to be Friend but I'd settle for You Are too.

WildHearted 01-15-2014 07:05 PM

Stevie: I would haved like to hear either Moonlight or Anabel Lee as Mac pieces.

Lindsey: Definitely Gone Too Far, for me. It already sounds super Mac-y so I can imagine it doing really well within FM.

Christine: Got a Hold on Me or Friend, either would be good choices imo.

MikeVielhaber 01-15-2014 07:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Macfanforever (Post 1117553)
Yes .I'm probably used of hearing medleys when I go to the country concerts.
They seem to have a habit doing medleys.

Genesis used to play medleys to cover the Peter Gabriel stuff and even early Phil Collins stuff that was really long and would take up too much of the show if they played them in full. They did many medleys, but one of the main ones was the "In The Cage" medley which would would begin with a full version of "In the Cage" and then from there do bits of other songs (that varied tour to tour and pretty much exclusively instrumental sections) and then end with a full version of "Afterglow". So within the medley were two full songs. I didn't mind it in that context. Although I'm sure many would've loved to hear full versions of the "bits".

louielouie2000 01-15-2014 08:02 PM

Christine: Friend
Lindsey: Down On Rodeo
Stevie: You May Be The One

elle 01-15-2014 08:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WildHearted (Post 1117597)
Stevie: I would haved like to hear either Moonlight or Anabel Lee as Mac pieces.

Lindsey: Definitely Gone Too Far, for me. It already sounds super Mac-y so I can imagine it doing really well within FM.

Christine: Got a Hold on Me or Friend, either would be good choices imo.

love Gone Too Far, it's on my request list for him.

elle 01-15-2014 08:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by louielouie2000 (Post 1117602)
Christine: Friend
Lindsey: Down On Rodeo
Stevie: You May Be The One

Rodeo also on my standing request list. i even requested it at several FM concerts this year, just as a continuing joke. gorgeous gorgeous song. but he doesn't need the band for it, he did some beautiful completely solo off-the-cuff upon request versions. i'd rather he keeps Rodeo for OMS tours and do a song which needs a whole band sound.

yes on YMBTO. Everybody Loves You would be even better. parts of the duet on it remind me of SN/LB duet-ting on Twisted, and i love that sound.

michelej1 01-15-2014 09:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WildHearted (Post 1117597)
Lindsey: Definitely Gone Too Far, for me. It already sounds super Mac-y so I can imagine it doing really well within FM.

I'm a sucker for Gone Too Far.

Michele

michelej1 01-15-2014 09:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeVielhaber (Post 1117599)
Genesis used to play medleys to cover the Peter Gabriel stuff and even early Phil Collins stuff that was really long and would take up too much of the show if they played them in full. They did many medleys, but one of the main ones was the "In The Cage" medley which would would begin with a full version of "In the Cage" and then from there do bits of other songs (that varied tour to tour and pretty much exclusively instrumental sections) and then end with a full version of "Afterglow". So within the medley were two full songs. I didn't mind it in that context. Although I'm sure many would've loved to hear full versions of the "bits".

I think there are blending possibilities like with Stevie solo, Dreams and OTR.

For the group, you could definitely "sample" Tango in the Night into another FM song very smoothly, in the "bits" you described.

Michele

Japhry 01-16-2014 02:47 AM

Lindsey: "Soul Drifter" or any number of songs from Out of the Cradle would work.

Stevie: I think "Fall From Grace" would be better suited by and perhaps even more powerful as done by Fleetwood Mac. John's bass treatment could really give this a boost.

Christine: Calumny

KenB 01-16-2014 08:23 PM

For Lindsey, the correct answer is clearly "Deep Dense."

Among those suggested by others in this thread, I'd also like t hear GOS or Gone Too Far done with Mac.

Trouble already sounds like a Mac song. No need to make it one. (Although I would like to hear the Mirage rehearsal of this song that someone else said exists.)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:24 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
© 1995-2003 Martin and Lisa Adelson, All Rights Reserved