The "In Your Dreams" Survivor Thread - Round Five
 

Here is what you have voted out so far:

Round One: Cheaper Than Free
Round One: My Heart
Round Two: Soldier's Angel
Round Two: Everybody Loves You
Round Three: Ghosts Are Gone
Round Three: New Orleans
Round Four: Secret Love
Round Four: Italian Summer


Onto Round five...

I know I'm really going out on a limb but I'm going to predict Moonlight as the winner :laugh:.

Moonlight. For the win! :blob2: just think that anything that can get most of the ledge to agree must be pure magic:laugh: also I gotta say I am impressed that the you may be the 1 army rallied the troops to save it and:lol: boot of secret love

OH MY GOSH this is too hard!!

Eh, it's going down this week.

It's funny....looks like people suddenly realized that "In Your Dreams" was still around. lol

This is getting HAAARD! lol

I really don't want In Your Dreams gone! Voted for YMBTO and WSS. Even though I actually like WSS.

You know what else is funny moonlight had consistently 0 votes :lol:until the very end when suddenly it would get 1 vote, well we all know who that was now

I can't vote any more. I really can't pick between any of these tracks. I love them all and they are her most consistent group of songs in years.

Probably wasted votes - Annabel Lee and Wide Sargasso Sea

WSS NEEDS to go. NEEDS to.

Really ♥ all these songs at this stage! *deep sigh* So here goes...

In Your Dreams - super catchy & upbeat song, which is actually a rarity in Stevie's catalog :lol: & Wide Sargasso Sea - probably Stevie's most sexually menacing lyrics eva~Love it! But it could have been shortened a tiny sliver ;) & besides I just couldn't vote off Annabel Lee yet. It's just classic classic >>> Stevie + Poe = Magic. Not to mention the ambiguous & unwavering Stevie as the androgynous protagonist.

The best have already been voted off, sadly.

:eek:

opinions are opinions, i suppose

In Your Dreams and Wide Sargasso Sea.

IYD is a great song, but, if I compare it to Stevie's other title tracks, I find it... lacking. As for WSS, it's the weakest song left, imo.. although, saying that, I've found myself listening to it loads lately and enjoying it far more than I used to.

I really don't wanna do this. I don't know what I keep coming back to this thread...I guess "it's like Narnia":lol:. But I'm gonna have to go with "IYD" and "WSS". Even though I totally love those songs...but if I had to choose any those are the ones I would choose.

I did. I just voted for one last time and I was reading the other thread and someone said they were surprised it was still around and I said to myself, "What:eek:. That insipid song is still in the running when people are trying to ditch YMBTO. How can that be?" See, IYD is so uninteresting that you don't even realize it's there, which is not a bad thing. It means it doesn't stink either.

Michele

Again, I vote for YMBTO and IYD. The others are my favorites and the only one out of those I could possibly vote for is FWIW.

I'll give everyone a kiss and a little over the sweater action if YMBTO stays.

Words I've been waiting to hear you say since I first joined the ledge!:blob2:

Yeahhhhhhhhh!!

I missed the last round, wasting time in my normal life instead of here on the Ledge, but am glad to see 'Italian Summer' has bitten the big one.

Very tough from this point on, but gonna go for IYD and WSS. Love 'em both, but there's more in the others, for me.

Also, add me to the list of people who can't understand why YMBTO isn't more beloved?? That song has maybe my favourite moment on the album: Lori and Sharon's harmonies on 'like some seabirds'....... ahh, chills :blob1:

because its the ledge. YMBO is a classic, solid winner. Stevie didn't mention it enough, that's why. It doesn't have the story, like the others

:laugh::laugh: Blimey, to me the entire song is the story. It's got some of the least oblique writing about her and LB that she's ever done. But maybe you're right. :)

For the live of all things, someone vote for WSS and save YMBTO's Poor soul.

I will be very upset if WSS is voted off, but YMTO stays.

Annabelle Lee and In Your Dreams

You must mean "My Heart" and "Cheaper Than Free".

This album very quickly got into "it's hard to pick one" category because it's so good. People are booting songs not because they think the songs are bad but rather to save a song they really love. I feel for those of you who love YMBTO intensely. I don't feel that way, but I can understand why you do.

very true!!!!

YMBTO fans are turning these into real cliffhangers! "Keep going, girl! waaaaooooo!"

:thumbsup: :wavey:

^I know. These rounds are giving me ulcers.

They're giving me the creeps! What kind of world am I living in, anyway!