"Out of the Cradle" SURVIVOR ROUNDS 1-3
 

The Rules:

Please familiarize yourself with these rules because these are the standards by which votes will be counted.


The way the hosts post: We will always post official results in the same manner (+4 Red) and our goal is to make it easy for you guys to follow what’s going on. So if you’re confused, look for our posts. We will announce a) when the voting period has begun and ended b) who has immunity and c) results.

VOTING:

- Voting periods begin AFTER immunity is assigned and ends at 5:59 EST that night. Either sodascouts or I will post an official beginning and ending announcement. If your votes are before or after those posts, then they do not count. See below for how immunity works.

- When you vote, type 1) The round number and 2) the name of the song in your subject line and ONLY that. We will tally the votes by the subject line, so if it ain’t in the subject it doesn’t count!
- Votes can NOT be changed once they’re posted. We count your first vote and that is all.

- If there is a tiebreaker, then ALL votes from ALL previous rounds are tallied and whoever has the most prior votes is eliminated. That’s the way it’s done on the real show, that’s the way it’s done here. If there is a complete tie with prior votes (Murphy’s Law), then we’ll have a sudden-death immunity question ready which will allow someone to make the call themselves between those two (or more) songs.

IMMUNITY:

- After we tally the scores, we will announce the results and post an immunity question/puzzle/etc. and await a response post. In order to be considered, the answering post must contain both the following: 1) the correct answer and 2) the choice for immunity. When we get that post, it will then be VERIFIED by us in bright red letters confirming who has immunity this round. So again, if we haven’t posted, nothing is official! Once we confirm immunity, the voting period begins. There is no immunity question for Round 1; we'll start that on Round 2.

Thanks for playing and have a good time!

The songs for Out of the Cradle survivor are:

- Don't Look Down
- Wrong
- Countdown
- All My Sorrows
- Soul Drifter
- This is the Time
- You Do Or You Don't
- Street of Dreams
- Surrender the Rain
- Doing What I Can
- Turn It on
- This Nearly Was Mine
- Say We'll Meet Again

*Note that we did not count the introduction tracks as candidates.*

Let the games begin!

ROUND 1 BEGINS NOW.

Round 1: Surrender the Rain
 

The one song I just couldn't stand to get accustomed to. It's too dentist-office-waiting-room for me.

Round 1 - 'Doing What I Can'
 

It's this albums 'Family Man', imho...

Round 1 - All My Sorrows
 

My least fave song. I don't hate it, it's just my least fave. :)

Round 1: Say We'll Meet Again
 

..........

Round 1: Wrong
 

Love every song in it's own right, but this is the one I'm least attached to. :sorry:

Round 1: All My Sorrows
 

I guarantee this will probably be the easiest part of this Survivor for me. I love this song very much, but the others? They're my babies. :xoxo:

round 1: Say We'll Meet Again
 

...........

Round 1 - All My Sorrows
 

My least favorite track. I like this song, but I love all the others.

Round 1: Wrong
 

Round 1 - "Street Of Dreams"
 

Snooze-alert! The one and only song I skip on the album.

("All My Sorrows" is truly beautiful, but I see it's going to be picked off first. *sighs* :( )

Round 1 - All My Sorrows

Street of Dreams????? I'm shocked! :shocked:

I know. :o
It's funny -- there are only a measly two Lindsey songs that I don't care for, and they both happen to be songs that pretty much everyone else feels are among his very best. :shrug:

I should have been smarter and voted against "Say We'll Meet Again" though -- would have spared "All My Sorrows" for at least one round.

Round 1 - This is the Time
 

There are no bad songs on this album, but like others, there's a least favorite and this is it for me. Apparently not for anyone else, though. lol

Neal, remember to put the song title in the subject line for it to be counted. :)

Don't forget to put your vote in the subject line for it to be counted! :)

Surrender the Rain
 

.......................

Round 1: All My Sorrows
 

..........

Done. :wavey:

:sorry:

Round 1 All My Sorrows
 

***********

I'm probably too late to save it, but I dug up the Kingston Trio's version of All My Sorrows anyway for anyone to hear. I think LB did a great job on it, I love it. Sorry to see it go :(

All My Sorrows

Round 1 - Soul Drifter
 

Gotta go with my heart and Soul Drifter is the most bland track I think.

Round 1: All My Sorrows...
 

....soon forgotten.

Round 1 : all my sorrows
 

I don't really care for that one .

rondje1: all my sorrows
 

..............................

Round 1: Say We'll Meet Again
 

Its important to remember that nobody
falls into a simple set of labels

:wavey:

Wow, I LOVE Lindsey's version compared to this. I think they chose all the wrong harmonies in this original version... Lindsey's just seems a lot more emotional/powerful than this.

Round 1: All My Sorrows
 

.......................

I love John Stewart and a lot of the old Kingston Trio stuff, but yes, Lindsey's version was definitely an improvement :)
Especially live.. that power of understatement, you know.

Round 1- All My Sorrows
 

Results for Round 1
 

Results for Round 1


All My Sorrows – 10
Say We’ll Meet Again – 3
Soul Drifter – 3
Surrender the Rain – 2
Wrong – 2
Doing What I Can – 1
Street of Dreams – 1
This is the Time – 1

With a landslide of 10 votes, “All My Sorrows” is the first song eliminated from Out of the Cradle survivor. “All My Sorrows,” please leave the tribal council area immediately. The rest of you may return to the camp.

Breakdown of Votes:
All My Sorrows – wondergirl9847
All My Sorrows – Nico
All My Sorrows – Patti
All My Sorrows – Karlie
All My Sorrows – golden braid
All My Sorrows – ontheEdgeof17
All My Sorrows – LINDSEY#1FAN
All My Sorrows – shackin’up
All My Sorrows – AliP
All My Sorrows – Dark Angel
Say We’ll Meet Again – CreepingDeath
Say We’ll Meet Again – Mari
Say We’ll Meet Again – msLinds
Soul Drifter – trackaghost
Soul Drifter – Lux
Soul Drifter – ReFleetwoodMac
Surrender the Rain – rezamatic
Surrender the Rain – AliceLover
Wrong – dissention
Wrong – GateandGarden
Doing What I Can – Neal
Street of Dreams – Johnny Stew
This is the Time – sodascouts



----------------


The songs in play:
Don't Look Down
Wrong
Countdown
Soul Drifter
This is the Time
You Do Or You Don't
Street of Dreams
Surrender the Rain
Doing What I Can
Turn It on
This Nearly Was Mine
Say We'll Meet Again

Voted off:
All My Sorrows 09/10/05

Immunity:
What song on OOTC was a favorite of Lindsey’s father?

This Nearly Was Mine!

Immunity for Say We'll Meet Again

Immunity: This Nearly Was Mine, Song Choice: Soul Drifter
 

Immunity: This Nearly Was Mine, Song Choice: Soul Drifter



Soul Dirfter is not my favorite but the genius of the opening dulcimer sounds which are actually multiple VSO'd electric guitars needs to be saved a little longer

I was first!

Yep!

SAY WE'LL MEET AGAIN is immune.

BEGIN ROUND 2!

Round 2: Soul Drifter
 

..........

Round 2 - Soul Drifter
 

..................

Round 2: Say We'll Meet Again
 

.................

This Nearly Was Mine
 

It's good, but it's an instrumental and he didn't write it.