Closing Track Survivor - Round 12
 

The cutoff time for Round 12 will be Tuesday at 9pm EST...


Frozen Love
Gold Dust Woman
No Questions Asked (voted off - Round 9)
The Second Time (voted off - Round 7)
Paper Doll (voted off - Round 5)
Goodbye Baby
The Highwayman (voted off - Round 11)
Beauty And The Beast
Has Anyone Ever Written Anything For You (voted off - Round 10)
I Still Miss Someone (voted off - Round 3)
Desert Angel (voted off - Round 1)
Jane (voted off - Round 2)
Rhiannon (piano version) (voted off - Round 4)
Gate And Garden (voted off - Round 6)
Love Is (voted off - Round 8)



let the voting for Round 12 begin..... :woohoo:

Round 12 Goodbye Baby
 

Like the demo much better.

Beauty And The Beast
 

I like it better live. It is hard to choose now. Goodbye baby is my favorite closing track of any recent album, FM or solo. It worked well live too. I love the power of Frozen Love and the moodiness of Gold Dust Woman.

Gold Dust Woman
 

This was not an easy decision to make, but i'm gonna have to go with "Gold Dust Woman" because I feel that "Songbird" really should have closed 'Rumours' instead... I think these other 3 songs are better closers, imo.. "Gold Dust Woman" doesn't end well, and really shouldn't have been a closing track...

:shocked: We agree.


My vote is Gold Dust Woman. Side 1 should have been Side 2 and vice versa.

The world must be coming to an end.. :nod:

Round 12 - Gold Dust Woman
 

Rock on.....

Beauty and the Beast, (I know some will disagree)
 

Beauty and the Beast
 

:shocked: Usually, I do agree with you. Not this time! :laugh: I love how GDW ends! All that weirdness? Very cool.

Anyhow... on to my vote: toss up between BATB and GB. I love BATB better LIVE - but this is about closers, right? I think Goodbye Baby is a better closer. So I vote off Beauty and the Beast. Wah.

Frozen Love
 

**************

Round 12 BATB
 

-------------

Round & Round #12: "Goodbye Baby".
 

Even though you can't find a better lullaby (in a good way) easily.

Goodbye Baby
 

....................

Goodbye Baby
 

Buh-Byyyyyyyyyyyy

Round 12
 

'Frozen Love'

i agree! however, i think it definately should have faded out instead of just ending abrubtly... it's too sudden of an ending to close an album.. if it had slowly faded out as all the "weirdness" ( :lol: ) was happening, it would have been a better closer, imo ;)

Round 12 - Goodbye Baby
 

*****************

12 - Gdw
 

-------------

how could you :mad:

Goodbye Baby
 

The other songs left are much stronger album closers...especially Gold Dust Woman, what a prefect end to a perfect album.

Beauty and the Beast.
 

Though that was a tough decision. :cool:

Round 12: Beauty and the Beast
 

..........

Gold Dust Woman

goodbye baby
 

can't really listen to it after hearing The Tower--so beautiful, and such a wonderful vocal. one of my favorite vocals of hers of all time for me. It recalls Carole King, I've always thought.

Goodbye Baby

I feel the same way. I really don't like the vocals on the beginning of the SYW version. The demo is amazing though :nod:

Here are the final results for Round 12....


Goodbye Baby: 8 votes
Beauty And The Beast: 6 votes
Gold Dust Woman: 5 votes
Frozen Love: 3 votes




"Goodbye Baby"... i hope your heart's not broken.. but you have been voted off ... bubye!

.. on to Round 13 :angel: