The Ledge

The Ledge (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/index.php)
-   Lindsey Buckingham (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Lindsey FM vs Lindsey Solo (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/showthread.php?t=19647)

ontheEdgeof17 05-31-2005 11:43 AM

Lindsey FM vs Lindsey Solo
 
Ah....It's only fair. ;)


Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper :lol:

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live)
vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

Mari 05-31-2005 11:54 AM

Yay! you kinda beat me too it.. well, I was too lazy to search out song titles, but anyway ;)

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble THIS is a tough one!!

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

Mac: 4
Solo: 7

CreepingDeath 05-31-2005 12:08 PM

Big Love (live) vs. Doing What I Can

Caroline vs. Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs. Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs. Trouble

Tusk vs. Wrong

Peacekeeper vs. Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs. Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs. Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs. Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs. This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs. Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs. Go Insane (live)

Miss Vicky 05-31-2005 12:29 PM

This is hard. I don't normally even make a distinction between Lindsey FM and Lindsey solo. As long as he's singing, it's all good but let me see...

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo (Which version of Bleed are we talking about? If it's the one from the Dance than I like it bettter, if not than Rodeo gets my vote!)

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong (Again, are we talking studio or live versions here? 'Cause any live version of Tusk is better than wrong, but Wrong is better than the studio version of Tusk)

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper (I can't vote on this one. I've never heard the solo Peacekeeper. But also, I'm not that fond of the SYW studio version but love the live version on the bonus disc.)

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road (SHN is still a fav, despite being sampled and nearly ruined by Kid Rock.)

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum (Studio version is great, but the live ones from the Tusk and Mirage tours are ssoo much better!)

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time (Are we talking studio or live version on So Afraid? 'Cause I CAN'T STAND THE STUDIO VERSION! But I LOVE the song in any live version.)

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Awayvs Go Insane (live)

Can you tell that I usually like LB's live performances better than the studio versions? :D

shackin'up 05-31-2005 12:50 PM

Big Love (live) vs. Doing What I Can

Caroline vs. Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs. Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs. Trouble

Tusk vs. Wrong

Peacekeeper vs. Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs. Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs. Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs. Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs. This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs. Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs. Go Insane (live)

9 FM
3 LB

but I don't think his best solowork is to choose.

dissention 05-31-2005 12:52 PM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper (solo)

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

rhiannon1119 05-31-2005 01:03 PM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo *Impossible to choose

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter *Impossible to choose

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

FM-11
Solo-4

:) Michelle

dudden22 05-31-2005 01:25 PM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper :lol:

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road :laugh: (I forgot about this one)

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

fm 6
Solo 5

lagringader&r 05-31-2005 02:05 PM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live

FM - 7
Solo - 5

Serrart 05-31-2005 04:34 PM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live)
vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

FM 9
Solo 3

Romy

WelshWitchPMD 05-31-2005 04:44 PM

OHH this is toughy for sure!


Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper :lol:

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live) I like the studio version, too

trackaghost 05-31-2005 05:35 PM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

chiliD 05-31-2005 11:39 PM

Big Love (studio) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny (studio) vs Bang The Drum
Not That Funny (live) vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live)
vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

face of glass 06-01-2005 04:25 AM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew *

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo *

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

FM - 7
Solo - 5

* = tough decisions

GypsySorcerer 06-01-2005 06:46 AM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

face of glass 06-01-2005 09:38 AM

More:

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup *

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing

* = another tough decision

Mari 06-01-2005 09:48 AM

Ah cool, more.

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams

Walk A Thin Line
vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing

mondaymornin1 06-01-2005 09:49 AM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter ---nope, can't do it!

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

mondaymornin1 06-01-2005 09:53 AM

More:

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup *

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing

I've never heard "Given Thing" or "Cool Water" :shrug: Does that make me a lesser fan?? Or do I just not know the right people? ;)

face of glass 06-01-2005 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mondaymornin1
I've never heard "Given Thing" or "Cool Water" :shrug: Does that make me a lesser fan?? Or do I just not know the right people? ;)

"Cool Water" was the b-side of the "Gypsy" single, while "Given Thing" was amongst Lindsey's Village Recorder Demos and is one of the Gift Of Screws outtakes. BuckinghamNicks.net has "Cool Water" available for download. Keep on watching ThrownDown.net and you might find "Given Thing" too. ;)

mondaymornin1 06-01-2005 10:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by face of glass
"Cool Water" was the b-side of the "Gypsy" single, while "Given Thing" was amongst Lindsey's Village Recorder Demos and is one of the Gift Of Screws outtakes. BuckinghamNicks.net has "Cool Water" available for download. Keep on watching ThrownDown.net and you might find "Given Thing" too. ;)

Ahhhh! Thank you!

Hmmm, I was thinking I had the "Gypsy" single...maybe not. I think my 45 collection is still at my mom's house. :o Better go check!

CreepingDeath 06-01-2005 10:26 AM

More:

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain -Family Man is the worst LB song evah.

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing

trackaghost 06-01-2005 10:40 AM

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing

ontheEdgeof17 06-01-2005 10:43 AM

More:

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA <3 this song!

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows I don't like either, that much

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA ick, to both

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing

chiliD 06-01-2005 12:28 PM

More:

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup TIE!!

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA (you could put almost ANY song up against "Oh Diane" and I wouldn't pick "Oh Diane")

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing (aren't these the same song? :laugh: )

chiliD 06-01-2005 12:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CreepingDeath
-Family Man is the worst LB song evah.


Disagree.

Oh Diane
Not That Funny
(studio version)
I Want You
I Must Go
Love From Here, Love From There


are, to my ears, worse.

shackin'up 06-01-2005 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chiliD
Disagree.

Oh Diane
Not That Funny
(studio version)
I Want You
I Must Go
Love From Here, Love From There


are, to my ears, worse.

disagree. Not that funny is even one of his best. And the rest of these are not. But better than Family man....

sigh...opinions..... ;)

shackin'up 06-01-2005 01:17 PM

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing

ontheEdgeof17 06-01-2005 01:17 PM

Family Man is one of my favorites.


Go fig. :cool:

shackin'up 06-01-2005 01:19 PM

ChiliD, you did not choose between Down endless Street and Street of Dreams!

chiliD 06-01-2005 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shackin'up
ChiliD, you did not choose between Down endless Street and Street of Dreams!


OOOPS!

Down Endless Street


I liked "Street Of Dreams" until I heard Lindsey play it live...didn't like how he did it and it tainted how I listened to the OotC version thereafter.

CreepingDeath 06-01-2005 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chiliD
Disagree.

Oh Diane
Not That Funny
(studio version)
I Want You
I Must Go
Love From Here, Love From There


are, to my ears, worse.

Well, maybe I was being a tad dramatic (you know how us Chiffon Heads can be). The ones you listed are just as bad as Family Man. I would throw in Drancing Across The USA also.

Hawkeye 06-01-2005 07:01 PM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

Mac: 4
Solo: 7[/QUOTE]

wondergirl9847 06-02-2005 10:14 AM

Here ya go...
 
Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper (solo!!!)

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road (this is the song that started it all for me and my crazy fandom)

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down (GAH!! Too frickin' difficult!)

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

PART TWO:

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup (ARG!!!!!)

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain (Love FM, but STR is frickin awesome!)

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA (Another one that started it all)

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams (Dammit...only because it makes me cry...love 'em both)

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing



Guess I'm dead even on both parts. This was mucho difficulto.

Lindsey Jr. 06-02-2005 02:03 PM

I like him in FM & solo. In both cases he has made great material as well as... not so great material. I won't post my lists here again, but the songs I like are in the majority, both solo and FM. :nod:

Miss Vicky 06-03-2005 12:58 AM

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA (This is a tough one!)

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA (this is an easy one, seeing how I can't stand Oh Diane)

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing (I can't choose - I've never heard Given Thing. :distress: )

glitter_fades 06-03-2005 02:31 PM

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper (solo!!!)

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time TIE! TOO HARD TO CHOOSE.

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live)

PART TWO:

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup TIE! Can't decide.

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain NOT EVEN CLOSE

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams TOUGH CALL

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing

Nico 06-06-2005 12:26 PM

Coolness!

Big Love (live) vs Doing What I Can (I really just love the studio version of BL so much)

Caroline vs Johnny Stew

Bleed To Love Her vs Down on Rodeo (Any version, though I am preferable to the "Dance" version I suppose)

Save Me a Place vs Trouble

Tusk vs Wrong

Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper...uh, I have only heard the one on SYW, so...yeah, I can't really vote here.

Second Hand News vs Holiday Road

Can't Go Back vs Don't Look Down...yeah, never heard the first song. I know, I know... :sorry:

Not That Funny vs Bang The Drum (I love this song man! It's crazy and manic and very sexy at the same time)

I'm So Afraid vs This is the Time (Only if it is the live version of ISA. If not, then I choose the other one.)

Eyes of the World (live) vs Soul Drifter

Steal Your Heart Away vs Go Insane (live) <--- :xoxo:

Empire State vs. That's How We Do It In LA...once again, I don't know the first song. But the second one ROCKS!

Tango In The Night vs. Play In The Rain

Murrow vs. Loving Cup

Cool Water vs. All My Sorrows

Family Man vs. Surrender The Rain

You And I Part One vs. D.W. Suite...I never heard part one, just part two. Dammit!! :(

Oh Diane vs. Dancing Across The USA (never heard Oh Diane, but I adore DATUSA)

Down Endless Street vs. Street Of Dreams (soooo beautiful)

Walk A Thin Line vs. Shadow Of The West

That's Enough For Me vs. Given Thing

I probably need to listen to more Lindsey songs, or get the Mirage album already.

GateandGarden 06-06-2005 11:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nico
Peacekeeper vs Peacekeeper...uh, I have only heard the one on SYW, so...yeah, I can't really vote here.

Jen! I thought you had the GOS songs? Isn't the solo "Peacekeeper" part of those? Do I need to send you that sometime, too? (You have so much Lindsey stuff coming from me in your e-mail! :nod: ) :D


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:27 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
© 1995-2003 Martin and Lisa Adelson, All Rights Reserved