The Ledge

The Ledge (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/index.php)
-   Chit Chat (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   What Country is the best? (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/showthread.php?t=16859)

Hawkeye 11-11-2004 11:18 PM

What Country is the best?
 
before I started coming to The Ledge, I always figured the United States to be hands down the greatest country by far blowing away all the other countries out of the water and onto high mountains. But, many here believe this country is now crap, and I've almost started to believe you. But then I remeber this is just a freaking message board. SOOO I'll stick with America being the best country (although I despise our legal system) So what country do you think is the best to live. Is it England, Canada, Austrailia, Ittally, Germany...

strandinthewind 11-11-2004 11:23 PM

I have been to at least 20 other countries - probably more. While ALL have their advantages and disadvantages, of those and based on the limited time I was there, I can say the US has the most freedom hands down even though the US clearly has its problems. Thus, I pick the US based on my experience.

strandinthewind 11-11-2004 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
What the f*ck kind of question is that? Why do Americans have this belief that there's must be the best country, and if not, that there atleast is a 'best' country?

Fine, if you're going to judge which is the 'best' country, I'll go with New Zealand. You could go with the Scandanavian nations in terms of living standards. American living standards are lower than Australia, NZ, Canada and most European countries. Their citizens also have fewer freedoms than the countries mentioned, so America is basically out of the running if you're going to do a 'best' country scale.

It's a ridiculous concept and really shows the philosophy of the way Americans are brought up. You're not better than other countries, that's a load of **** that ought to be removed from the curriculum.

DO YOU EVER JUST TAKE ANYTHING LIGHTLY :laugh:

strandinthewind 11-11-2004 11:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
That's a load of ****e.

You were there with me? You saw what I saw? If you had bothered to read what I wrote, I said I based it on my experience :rolleyes: :wavey:

Hawkeye 11-11-2004 11:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
What the f*ck kind of question is that? Why do Americans have this belief that there's must be the best country, and if not, that there atleast is a 'best' country?

Fine, if you're going to judge which is the 'best' country, I'll go with New Zealand. You could go with the Scandanavian nations in terms of living standards. American living standards are lower than Australia, NZ, Canada and most European countries. Their citizens also have fewer freedoms than the countries mentioned, so America is basically out of the running if you're going to do a 'best' country scale.

It's a ridiculous concept and really shows the philosophy of the way Americans are brought up. You're not better than other countries, that's a load of **** that ought to be removed from the curriculum.

I think it's a great question I asked. What country we like best is no then the countless disscussions of Lindsey vs, Stevie. And I have a feeling they'll be less fighting here then there :laugh:

strandinthewind 11-11-2004 11:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
Oh Mr Rolling Eyes, I thought you said you'd been down here....?

I am pleading the Fifth regarding where I have been and what I have done while there :laugh:

AND - the roll eyes thingee was supposed to be this one ;) - I clicked on the wrong one :sorry:

strandinthewind 11-11-2004 11:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
That question might be lighthearted but its roots are disturbing. Americans crap on about being the greatest country in the world, it would never occur to me to ask such a question. It's kind of arrogant.

I think the phrase "So what country do you think is the best to live" indicates it was not a my brother can beat up your brother competition :laugh: I mean I can assure you that to me, living in London would be WILDLY better than living in Odessa, Texas :eek: But, the reverse could be true for another person. Thus, the point of the question :wavey:

strandinthewind 11-11-2004 11:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
Also Americans in general (note the "in general" bit) have limited knowledge about most countries let alone how they are run. I didn't mean that to be a judgement on specific people here, it kind of a well known generalisation outside of the US that worldly knowledge extends only to the US borders. If you're brought up with that propaganda telling you America is the greatest country with the most freedoms and where everyone is brave, yet they teach you very little about how other countries are run and that most western countries actually have more freedoms, then you're going to come back with a "America is the greatest" response. It just bugs me and judging by every single person I know here at home and in other nations, I think I can say it bugs nearly all non-Americans.

That is so deliciously snobbish of you :laugh:

strandinthewind 11-11-2004 11:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
Fine, you're forgiven. Hand me back the divorce papers then.

I never even opened the file!!!!!!!!! :woohoo: :woohoo:

Hawkeye 11-11-2004 11:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by strandinthewind
I think the phrase "So what country do you think is the best to live" indicates it was not a my brother can beat up your brother competition :laugh: I mean I can assure you that to me, living in London would be WILDLY better than living in Odessa, Texas :eek: But, the reverse could be true for another person. Thus, the point of the question :wavey:

Exactly this isn't about which country can beat the others up. This comes down to the littlest things. Like how this thread idea was sparked. It was sparked by the Britcom disscussion in the TV thread. I personally love the apparently stupidness of American TV. That's where I got thew idea for this thread.

amber 11-11-2004 11:48 PM

It seemed an odd question to me. Although I probably know some of the main factors that Hawkeye had in mind when he thought it up, I just thought it would be an extremely subjective decision to make, involving many factors and personal tastes. One of first things that i thought of, in addition to the gov'ts and legal systems of different countries, was things like weather, landscape, culture...I mean there really are to many totally different things that could make a country "best" isn't there? I was thinking Canada was nice, but then i was thinking it was butt ass cold. :) And on and on. Also, I'm not sure that i would think of asking this question either :confused:

GateandGarden 11-11-2004 11:59 PM

I can't help but echo Lux's sentiments. I can't understand why we should talk about which country is the best. Even if it's intended as a joke, it seems like asking for trouble to me.

Hillary

Hawkeye 11-11-2004 11:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by amber
It seemed an odd question to me. Although I probably know some of the main factors that Hawkeye had in mind when he thought it up, I just thought it would be an extremely subjective decision to make, involving many factors and personal tastes. One of first things that i thought of, in addition to the gov'ts and legal systems of different countries, was things like weather, landscape, culture...I mean there really are to many totally different things that could make a country "best" isn't there? I was thinking Canada was nice, but then i was thinking it was butt ass cold. :) And on and on. Also, I'm not sure that i would think of asking this question either :confused:

Another thing, I HATE Snakes. It's one BIG fear. I jump if I see a picture of one. So that takes Austrailia right off my running. I would never even vist a country so full of snakes.

strandinthewind 11-12-2004 12:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GateandGarden
I can't help but echo Lux's sentiments. I can't understand why we should talk about which country is the best. Even if it's intended as a joke, it seems like asking for trouble to me.

Hillary

So, when you pick someplace to live, how do you do it? You choose the one that is best suited for you, whatever your individual criteria may be. For me, it is here. But, I could readily live in Paris as well. Honestly, I think you guys are blowing this WAY out of proportion. But, so be it :laugh:

estranged4life 11-12-2004 12:18 AM

I prefer...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hawkeye
before I started coming to The Ledge, I always figured the United States to be hands down the greatest country by far blowing away all the other countries out of the water and onto high mountains. But, many here believe this country is now crap, and I've almost started to believe you. But then I remeber this is just a freaking message board. SOOO I'll stick with America being the best country (although I despise our legal system) So what country do you think is the best to live. Is it England, Canada, Austrailia, Ittally, Germany...

the country here in the US because those darnnabbit city folk are so immoral & sin filled...With their loud car stereos & body piercings & Satan worship & baggy clothes :lol:

Seriously, Even though I would love to go to Japan, A wish I had LONG before the US political schenanigans of the past several years, I would NEVER live elsewhere....

Btw, I think "Kerplackastan" is the best country :lol:

Brian j.

heyjupiter678 11-12-2004 01:09 AM

If I could afford to move there, I'd live in England. I read an article a couple of weeks ago that said less than half of the population of England claims to belong to a religion, compared with almost 90% here in the US. :shocked: That's reason enough for me to cross the Atlantic. :nod: ;)

tuigirl 11-12-2004 03:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by heyjupiter678
If I could afford to move there, I'd live in England. I read an article a couple of weeks ago that said less than half of the population of England claims to belong to a religion, compared with almost 90% here in the US. :shocked: That's reason enough for me to cross the Atlantic. :nod: ;)

Interesting Jupiter, that you would move to the UK for that reason and thats exactly why, this question is so random..what one person thinks would be a great place to live, is not, by another persons standards.An example of this is on the 4 yr vacation thread, where a fellow Ledgie has dreams of living in France and I posted my views of the place , having actually lived there.Like Strand said we can only base our opinions on our own experiences, personally, I have lived in 4 countries and even then wouldn't dare offer a list of which were best..Lux..yet another indepth post on your thoughts :)

DownOnRodeo 11-12-2004 03:38 AM

Didn't know you were intrigued to go to Japan, Brian!

I was going to add that today I was looking through a Japanese high school geography textbook and there was a small chapter on 'other countries' (ie the US) but it was almost all about Japan. And yes, Japanese generally think that their country is the best. But don't we all 'love the one we're in'? It would suck to live in a country you thought was lame.

Of course there's good and bad points to each country based on personal preference. I love(d) living in Australia, but Japan is equally good for totally different reasons.

Younger Japanese are fascinated by the US, but many that I have spoken to who have visited there say it was an awesome trip but they'd never want to live there... I swear you could see a sort of harrowed, almost terrified gleam in their eyes as they said it! :laugh:

HomerMcvie 11-12-2004 05:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by heyjupiter678
If I could afford to move there, I'd live in England. I read an article a couple of weeks ago that said less than half of the population of England claims to belong to a religion, compared with almost 90% here in the US. :shocked: That's reason enough for me to cross the Atlantic. :nod: ;)

AMEN sister! (so to speak) What's this US obsession with religion? I don't get it, nor care to get it. Maybe penicillin can cure it. :lol:

Oh yeah. And I've found traditional country to be the best. This pop fodder must go.

Mari 11-12-2004 05:25 AM

hm, you know there've been tons of sociological researches and indexes etc. about this. I'll try to find some when I get home :)
I don't find my country the best to live in right now. Lots of racial violence the last few weeks, dunno if any of that news filtered through to the US...
Even though a newsarticle I read this morning said that elderly people have it better here than any other country in the world.
I think it depends on the person/personal circumstances anyway. You might be off great here if you're over 65, but not so great if you're disabled. Or if you're a muslim, right now.

tynan88 11-12-2004 06:00 AM

I think the idea of this thread is misguided and Lux is totally right in suggesting that Americans really are generally hated through the rest of the world, and it is because America don't realise the rest of the world hates them.
I don't care what country I live in to be honest though as long it is with the people I love and care about.

Tynan

Gypsy-Rhiannon 11-12-2004 07:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
This thread is titled "Which country is the best?". I don't care what you say, I still find that a ridiculous question.


I totally agree!

Gypsy-Rhiannon 11-12-2004 07:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by strandinthewind
So, when you pick someplace to live, how do you do it? You choose the one that is best suited for you, whatever your individual criteria may be.

Not entirely true. Most people don't pick. It's where they are born and they perhaps don't have the means to move to another country.

Gypsy-Rhiannon 11-12-2004 07:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by heyjupiter678
If I could afford to move there, I'd live in England. I read an article a couple of weeks ago that said less than half of the population of England claims to belong to a religion, compared with almost 90% here in the US. :shocked: That's reason enough for me to cross the Atlantic. :nod: ;)

But everything is so expensive here! And IMO we have a real problem with asylum seekers right now in the UK. Tony Blair will let anyone in! ;)

DownOnRodeo 11-12-2004 08:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gypsy-Rhiannon
Tony Blair will let anyone in! ;)

Hah! Exact opposite of John Howard. :rolleyes:

strandinthewind 11-12-2004 09:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gypsy-Rhiannon
Not entirely true. Most people don't pick. It's where they are born and they perhaps don't have the means to move to another country.

I know that - but I thought this thread was about wishing, etc., because the question was "So what country do you think is the best to live." So, I was not taking that into consideration. But, it is true.

Interestingly, I think most people like where they live and, while they might move to another city in their country, they would not want to move to a different country with a different culture, etc. I am not saying this applies to all people and I think it certainly applies less to countries with extreme poverty, faminem, disease, etc. But, even then, these people might be moving out of necessity and not because they do not like the place where they live.

Gypsy-Rhiannon 11-12-2004 09:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by strandinthewind
I know that - but I thought this thread was about wishing, etc. So, I was not taking that into consideration. But, it is true.

Interestingly, I think most people like where they live and, while they might move to another city in their country, they would not want to move to a different country with a different culture, etc. I am not saying this applies to all people and I think it certainly applies less to countries with extreme poverty, faminem, disease, etc. But, even then, these people might be moving out of necessity and not because they do not like the place where they live.

I often dream about moving to another country but I can't see myself ever doing it.

strandinthewind 11-12-2004 09:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gypsy-Rhiannon
I often dream about moving to another country but I can't see myself ever doing it.

I do too. AND England is waaaaaay up there. If I moved to England, I could see me with a house overlooking Green Park and a place on the Cornish Coast (though I have never been to the COrnish Coast :laugh: ) - Hey - I can dream can't I!!!!!! :laugh:

dissention 11-12-2004 09:43 AM

There isn't a "best" country and none of us could possibly be objective in answering such a question. I love America, but by no means is it "the best." It's a great country when it does good things, it sucks when it does bad things. This applies to ever country. But you'll never see me waving the flag or putting one on my car because I think it's an empty gesture.

dissention 11-12-2004 09:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by strandinthewind
So, when you pick someplace to live, how do you do it? You choose the one that is best suited for you, whatever your individual criteria may be. For me, it is here. But, I could readily live in Paris as well. Honestly, I think you guys are blowing this WAY out of proportion. But, so be it :laugh:

Yes, because we can all choose which country we want to live in, Jason. We all have enough money and smarts to attend open houses all across the globe to decide which country, city, and house is best suited to our needs. C'mon. :laugh:

ShangriLaTroubl 11-12-2004 09:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
Also Americans in general (note the "in general" bit) have limited knowledge about most countries let alone how they are run. I didn't mean that to be a judgement on specific people here, it kind of a well known generalisation outside of the US that worldly knowledge extends only to the US borders. If you're brought up with that propaganda telling you America is the greatest country with the most freedoms and where everyone is brave, yet they teach you very little about how other countries are run and that most western countries actually have more freedoms, then you're going to come back with a "America is the greatest" response. It just bugs me and judging by every single person I know here at home and in other nations, I think I can say it bugs nearly all non-Americans.


Actually in my experience, as a college student I learn a great deal about other countries. We are required to take courses devoted to other countries, IE : "Western Civilizations," "World History." It's american's choice if they do not learn of other countries, because it is fully presented to them. Sure Americans are most interested in things that go on in the USA (Elections, etc) as anyone in another country would be in their own affairs..
I do not think Americans are as ignorant as some might like to believe. Sure, Americans have a lot of pride, is there something wrong with that??

Chris

ShangriLaTroubl 11-12-2004 09:49 AM

Although my uncle, an American, loved America so much he moved to China this month and married a Chinese lady he met online...now tell me Americans are whacky, and I will agree with you!

Chris

dissention 11-12-2004 09:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ShangriLaTroubl
I do not think Americans are as ignorant as some might like to believe. Sure, Americans have a lot of pride, is there something wrong with that??

Chris

The prevailing attitude in foreign countries is that we are ignorant and that our actions speak for themselves. After 9/11, all Americans could do was ask why it happened. You can bet your ass that we were seen as ignorant because the rest of the country knew exactly why it happened and they didn't even live here. The people of this country are so isolated from the world that they know next to nothing about world affairs, world attitudes, or how their behavior is reflected across the globe. The election of George Bush proved that. This country is ignorant, there can be no denying it.

strandinthewind 11-12-2004 09:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dissention
Yes, because we can all choose which country we want to live in, Jason. We all have enough money and smarts to attend open houses all across the globe to decide which country, city, and house is best suited to our needs. C'mon. :laugh:

I swear you people :laugh: I get that. I never said any differently. But, I suppose you just cannot play "I wish I could live here" without being politically correct :laugh:

dissention 11-12-2004 09:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by strandinthewind
I swear you people :laugh: I get that. I never said any differently. But, I suppose you just cannot play "I wish I could live here" without being politically correct :laugh:

You said that people choose to live where their needs will best be suited. :shrug: I hate to disagree ( :laugh: ), but that just isn't true when it comes to which country you live in.

Serrart 11-12-2004 10:04 AM

I agree there can't be a best Country. I can say that Italy is a pretty good place to live in. We got great landscapes, people are friendly and creative. Every region carries on peculiar traditions that enrich our culture, and the aspect I love more is that we walk and breathe through history and art, and to have so much beauty under your eyes sometimes helps to put everything in perspective.

Obviously we got big problems too, the most serious is a prime minister who sees himself as a potential monarch, but hopefully we'll be able to send him home sooner or later. :nod:

Romy

strandinthewind 11-12-2004 10:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dissention
You said that people choose to live where their needs will best be suited. :shrug: I hate to disagree ( :laugh: ), but that just isn't true when it comes to which country you live in.

You all just amaze me :laugh: - I said "when you choose" - implying that if you chose or were making the choice. I get that all people cannot chose and never said any differently.

I mean this is a stupid what if kind on question. But, I suppose everything is a class war and evil, dumb, rich, uncaring Americans EVEN in a fantasyesq. where would you like to live type of thing - whatever.

wondergirl9847 11-12-2004 11:06 AM

Come on people!
 
You all know America is the greatest, bestest, most wonderful country in the entire universe!!!![/sarcasm]

There are good and bad things about every country in the world.

SuzeQuze 11-12-2004 03:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lux
This thread is titled "Which country is the best?". I don't care what you say, I still find that a ridiculous question.

I didn't mean it to be snobbish, I'm just trying to relate back the impression of American that is undeniably found throughout much of the world, that being one of arrogance and also ignorance. I don't know how to say it without sounding like a snob, but it's the truth.

I only started really learning about other countries when I worked for a multi-national firm and started meeting people from other countries and talking with them. When I look back on my education (pre-college) I find it kind of shocking and somewhat twisted how US centric (white US) it was. Particularly the way the story of the American Indian is told (not told).

I got a public education and I did not know that it was propaganda at the time. I'm not dissing my entire education by any means; I'm just saying that I wish more humility had been taught and a broader perspective of other cultures. Most educated people I know make an effort to understand other cultures. But if you have a high school education or less, and you don’t know anybody from another country, I think you are less inclined to be aware of them or care about them in this country. I have an uncle (not a college grad) who said he had no desire to ever go to another country and never would because we have everything here. :rolleyes:

This attitude is partly because we have lots of natural resources and such and have not “needed” other countries. Except Iraq for oil, hence the mess, ugh! At least not needing other countries is the perception. Of course everything is interdependent and we do need them.

But don’t hate the player, hate the game. These people just don’t know, please forgive them; they know not what they do!

wondergirl9847 11-12-2004 03:28 PM

Well...
 
The thing about America...is that the only people who aren't from other parts of the world....are the Native Americans. I have German, Irish, Italian and Cherokee blood in me, so I guess I don't, but yet, do belong here. LMAO!!

Kidding. Anyways, America is the ultimate melting pot, so when people start talking about Americans being ignorant and such, I laugh, because there are so many different races and cultures here. Are only "white" (how I hate that word in regards to race) people ignorant or are all Americans, no matter what race? Are Native Americans ignorant, are African-Americans, Australian-Americans? ;)

Ignorance knows no race, creed, religion, etc.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:27 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
© 1995-2003 Martin and Lisa Adelson, All Rights Reserved