You And I. But Which Part?
 

Can't choose. Part 1 does fit the mood of the album better then 2......but hell I love part 2. Hard choice. I made my own Tango with both parts on:nod:

Mick

Part 1 all the way. It's weird though, Part 2 actually sounds like it should be part 1, & vice versa. :p

Lovely songs, both...
 

Well, like bluefox4000 said, it's hard to choose. But I prefer Part I. Maybe because is rare, unusual, for its sound, the "game" with the voices...I can't explain, is just Wonderful!!! I heard first the Part II, and after this, I looked for Part I, and when I heard it...wow, just amazing! I always listen them together!
So, for me, Part I. Regards!

They both suck. I refuse to choose.

They are both nice songs. I went with Part 1 because I like the beat of the song better. :cool:

Love 'em both equally so I had to flip a coin - Part 2 won.

I think I prefer Part 1, but I'm not overly keen on either of them anyway.

It would have been awesome if Part 1 opened Tango and Part 2 closed it.

well i think You and I Part I is so clearly Buck-solo sounding while Part 2 is such a pure collab between himself and Christine. Also, it has a particularly perfect "ending" quality for the album. SO, I would choose Part 2 for being on the album (if I have to choose and if it has to be a two-sided rather than four-sided album ;).

As for which song I actually prefer, hmm.....

That's how i have it on my Tango. Works wonderfully. Part 1 segues nicely into Big love:nod:

Mick

Wow yes!!:cool::thumbsup:

Someone on here once said the original plan was to only include two Stevie songs on Tango but WB intervened and demanded two. If that's true, I'll bet You and I Part I originally had a place on the album.

I like Part II way better--though I prefer Christine's vocal on it, which is more organic, less "produced" than Lindsey's.

Part II is an atrocity compared to Part I. Part I is enough reason why TITN should be re-released like The White Album, Rumours and Tusk were.

Matt

LOL at your error.:laugh: