| skcin |
05-16-2007 12:17 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by GypsySorcerer
(Post 688161)
:laugh: :laugh: :laugh:
Jordin "She's Only 17" Sparks: I didn't care for the songs they chose for her. "She Works Hard for the Money"?!?!?!!?! And her favorite song is MMMMBop? :lol: Her vocals are decent, but she is a snoozefest for me.
|
When they said it was Maroon 5, I lol'd. :lol: I agreewith the song choice for Jordin - that tune's too silly/campy for me in general, let alone when a kid sings it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JazmenFlowers
(Post 688168)
I actually thought Jordin showed she was fighting to stay in. she added lots of high notes and vocal gymnastics. her voice was crisp and clear. I still don't like her, but I gotta give the girl props. I think she was stupid for saying Mmmbop was her favorite song and I wish she'd stop acting so ****ing fake and stupid.
Blake was ok. I wasn't really knocked out by anything. he's gone.
Melinda tore up the last two songs, but I thought she was way off on I Believe In You and Me. did no one else hear her crack during that one note and then struggle to hit a couple others? I really kinda realized that she doesn't have the range I thought she did. but she really kicked ass on her last two.
|
Really? I loved Blake! Jordin was spot on, but bored me this week. I did catch Melinda's voice cracking - but so did Lakisha's the other night. :shrug: I really think it was nerves as opposed to vocal ability.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Richard B
(Post 688218)
Interesting night.
Jordin - She's a fake. I really feel zipp sincerity from her when she sings. She's just an actress, and a bad one.
Blake - Now he's more real. I liked what he did tonight.
Melinda - Best of the night.
Who's going home? This is going to be close, real close. I'm hoping Jordin goes home and if not her, Blake.
|
Agree with all of the above. :nod:
Quote:
Originally Posted by gldstwmn
(Post 688226)
Just as the accusation that I singlehandedly ruined The Ledge. It's unfortunate that I am willing to see your side of the situation but you are unwilling to see mine. :shrug:
|
Good Christ, why can't you just let it go? :rolleyes: You continue to bring this up repeatedly in this thread even after Sugar asked everyone to drop it & they did. You're upset. We get it. If this is a last word thing, then you got it. Happy yet?
Quote:
Originally Posted by BlackWidow
(Post 688240)
Oh honey..I heard Melinda crack on the Whitney song. She has no head voice is why. Good belter..no upper register. I am shocked she was not called out on that!!! Blake was great..was it enough??? Not sure. Jordin has the edge and fits the Idol model. So...we will see...
|
Like I said, Lakisha has great range & her voice cracked too. It happens. Melinda hit the high "me" at the end without a problem. :shrug:
I'm honestly not sure who's going. I think it was really close last night - all 3 did really well. I called each number once around 9:45pm EST & got a busy signal for each contestant at one point. After that, I voted several times for Blake & got occasional busy signals - then, same with Melinda. So it's hard to say. |
