The Ledge

The Ledge (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/index.php)
-   Rumours (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Rank Mirage (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/showthread.php?t=56900)

jbrownsjr 03-05-2017 06:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tz5632 (Post 1202420)
1. Book of love
2. Gypsy
3. Straight back
4. Only over you
5. Eyes of the world
6. Love in store
7. Empire state
8. Hold me
9. That's alright
10. Oh Diane
11. Wish you were here
12. Can't go back

😀

Nice to see Book Of Love make someone's Number 1

GypsySorcerer 03-05-2017 10:27 PM

1) That's Alright
2) Gypsy
3) Hold Me
4) Book of Love
5) Eyes of the World
6) Wish You Were Here
7) Can't Go Back
8) Straight Back
9) Love in Store
10) Oh Diane
11) Empire State
12) Only Over You

BaronVonBielski 03-05-2017 11:02 PM

1. Love in Store
2. Hold Me
3. Gypsy
4. Eyes of the World
5. Oh Diane
6. Book of Love
7. Can't Go Back
8. Straight Back
9. Wish You Were Here
10. Only Over You
11. That's Alright
12. Empire State

Neal 03-06-2017 11:28 AM

1. Gypsy
2. Hold Me
3. Love In Store
4. Can't Go Back
5. Only Over You
6. Wish You Were Here
7. Book Of Love
8. Straight Back
9. That's Alright
10. Eyes Of The World
11. Oh Diane
12. Empire State

Justin Reach 03-08-2017 12:26 PM

1.Only Over You
2.Hold Me
3.Eyes Of The World
4.Gypsy
5.Wish You Were Here
6.Straight Back
7.Book Of Love
8.Love In Store
9.Empire State
10.Oh Diane
11.Can't Go Back
12.That's Alright

Netter75 03-08-2017 07:23 PM

The songs I almost always listen to:
1. Gypsy: Perfection. Some of Stevie's best vocals
2. Love in Store: Easy song to listen and hum along to, although I did prefer the livelier Mirage Tour version. Wouldn't be as notable if it didn't have all three members singing together.
3. Straight Back: I really shouldn't like this song as much as I do, as it's meandering structure would normally turn me off. But the layered vocals and keyboards always take me somewhere else.
4. Eyes of the World: Better in every live incarnation but still Lindsey's best song on the album. The guitar solo is one of his best.

Here are the ones that I sometimes skip but still generally like:
5. Hold Me: I used to despise this one but I've gradually grown fond of it. The Early Version helped me to do that a lot, as I thought it was fantastic. I also liked the boots of this song from McVie's solo tour and wished they'd sung it like that in the Mirage Tour.
6. That's Alright: it's a nice song, but the Alternate Version is bumped up a place or two
7. Book of Love: I always forget this song exists unless it randomly pops up. Not big on the verses but I do like the angsty chorus.
8. Oh Diane: Dumb song, but I really like the way the guitar sounds. At least it's short :) The lip-synced performance of this on Top of the Pops is also hilarious. I love it when Stevie and Christine try and pretend to sing that heavily-altered harmony.

These I almost always skip
9. Cant Go Back: I really like the instrumental of this song but the lyrics do nothing for me at all
10. Wish You Were Here: Very middle of the road McVie song. I feel nothing for it.
11. Only Over You: Really I like most of the song but those wails at the beginning... Chill me to the bone.

And finally, I HATE this song:
12. Empire State: So annoying. Embodies the worst of Lindsey's experimental side.

jbrownsjr 03-09-2017 10:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Justin Reach (Post 1202634)
1.Only Over You
2.Hold Me
3.Eyes Of The World
4.Gypsy
5.Wish You Were Here
6.Straight Back
7.Book Of Love
8.Love In Store
9.Empire State
10.Oh Diane
11.Can't Go Back
12.That's Alright

I've never seen this list before. Love it! Only Over You at #1...

jwd 03-26-2017 12:09 AM

1. Hold Me
2. Gypsy
3. That's Alright
4. Straight Back
5. Only Over You
6. Eyes Of The World
7. Book Of Love
8. Wish You Were Here
9. Love In Store
10. Oh Diane
11. Can't Go Back
12. Empire State

McLamb 05-25-2020 07:32 PM

Mirage is a great album.

Here is my ranking:

01. That's Alright
02. Love In Store
03. Hold Me
04. Wish You Were Here
05. Straight Back
06. Book Of Love
07. Only Over You
08. Can't Go Back
09. Gypsy
10. Empire State
11. Eyes Of The World
12. Oh Diane

tabruns 05-26-2020 05:45 PM

1. Gypsy
2. Straight Back
3. Hold Me
4. That's Alright
5. Wish You Were Here (alternate version)
6. Can't Go Back
7. Only Over You (alternate version)
8. Love In Store
9. Empire State
10. Oh Diane
11. Eyes Of The World <-- much better live
12. Book Of Love

I think "Smile At You" should have made the album in place of one of the Buckingham songs, "Book Of Love" IMO.

jcalzaretta 05-26-2020 08:23 PM

First of all. I love this record. So underrated.

1. Gypsy
2. That's Alright
3. Hold Me
4. Straight Back
5. Eyes of the World
6. Can't Go Back
7. Wish You Were Here
8. Book of Love
9. Love in Store
10. Oh Diane
11. Only Over You
12. Empire State

moon 05-29-2020 01:41 AM

Mirage is definitely my favourite album from the Rumours era. More than any other from this time and line-up.
Here's my ranking!

01 - Love In Store (Short but beautiful; backing vocals by Lindsey and SN are great!)
02 - Book Of Love (Lindsey's work with his own voice on this one is wonderful)
03 - Wish You Were Here (Once again, a nice way to close an album. Chris rules!)
04 - Can't Go Back (Simple and short but with a happy rhythm)
05 - Straight Back (Powerful, strong. A very rock song)
06 - Oh Diane (One of the first FM songs I love the most)
07 - Only Over You (Veeeery very soft and romantic. I like it!)
08 - That's Alright (Another "happy" song, simple and nice)
09 - Gypsy (The video of the song is one of the most beautiful videos ever)
10 - Hold Me (Nice tune, but lost a bit of shine for me after I discovered the rest of the songs)
11 - Empire State (Bad but not so bad...rare to hear something like this becoming from Lindsey)
12 - Eyes Of The World (Not my...kind of song, but I like it more than the live version, definitely!)

And my dear bonus tracks...

01 - If You Were My Love (Sparkly Piano version)
02 - Goodbye Angel
03 - Blue Monday
04 - Teen Beat

Macfan4life 05-29-2020 10:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moon (Post 1258279)
Mirage is definitely my favourite album from the Rumours era. More than any other from this time and line-up.
Here's my ranking!

01 - Love In Store (Short but beautiful; backing vocals by Lindsey and SN are great!)
02 - Book Of Love (Lindsey's work with his own voice on this one is wonderful)
03 - Wish You Were Here (Once again, a nice way to close an album. Chris rules!)
04 - Can't Go Back (Simple and short but with a happy rhythm)
05 - Straight Back (Powerful, strong. A very rock song)
06 - Oh Diane (One of the first FM songs I love the most)
07 - Only Over You (Veeeery very soft and romantic. I like it!)
08 - That's Alright (Another "happy" song, simple and nice)
09 - Gypsy (The video of the song is one of the most beautiful videos ever)
10 - Hold Me (Nice tune, but lost a bit of shine for me after I discovered the rest of the songs)
11 - Empire State (Bad but not so bad...rare to hear something like this becoming from Lindsey)
12 - Eyes Of The World (Not my...kind of song, but I like it more than the live version, definitely!)

And my dear bonus tracks...

01 - If You Were My Love (Sparkly Piano version)
02 - Goodbye Angel
03 - Blue Monday
04 - Teen Beat

Love your love for Love in Store. I find it impossible to rank songs especially off Mirage. However, Love In Store would be near the top for me too. Christine writes some of these beautiful and short love songs ever. Her lyrics are so honest that it makes you feel that first puppy love feeling in your stomach.
One of the best harmonies ever. Its almost like Lindsey and Stevie are in a doo whop band or something. Stevie's voice on Mirage is the best of her career so it makes it so much more special. I loved this song live too and I wish they would have done it during On With The Show. It also has a great melody. What an album opener!

I would sacrifice Oh Diane for the Mirage version of Smile at you. OMG another Stevie rocker on Mirage would be off the chain. Mirage needed that angry song but they kept it all music box joy. Stevie's jealousy is well documented. But I can see Lindsey's jealousy too especially Stevie coming off Bella Donna. Not only do they keep Stevie from ever having the lead off single but still only give her 3 songs. I think anyone could have seen Stevie had some amazing songs during this era. Its a shame they were not done during this time. Besides the double album Tusk (Angel). Stevie has also never had the lead song off any side of an album. IMHO it all sticks out like a sore thumb. The band secretly hated people thought Stevie was the lead singer of Fleetwood Mac so they went out of their way to convince others it was not the case. Write it down people because I just stuck up for Stevie!

HomerMcvie 05-29-2020 11:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Macfan4life (Post 1258289)
The band secretly hated people thought Stevie was the lead singer of Fleetwood Mac so they went out of their way to convince others it was not the case. Write it down people because I just stuck up for Stevie!

Well just color me disappointed!!!!:lol::lol::lol:



As much as I can't stand her now, I think it throws people for a loop when I name Bella Donna as one of my all time favorite albums. You CAN actually only love chapters of a person's(not that I'm calling $tevie a person....$he's more of a caricature these days :lol: ) career.

Macfan4life 05-29-2020 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HomerMcvie (Post 1258292)
Well just color me disappointed!!!!:lol::lol::lol:



As much as I can't stand her now, I think it throws people for a loop when I name Bella Donna as one of my all time favorite albums. You CAN actually only love chapters of a person's(not that I'm calling $tevie a person....$he's more of a caricature these days :lol: ) career.

Stevie just came off a huge solo album so I can see why they may have not wanted to put another gem on the album. However as a band, I think you should view songs as an entire band. Lindsey complained to Rolling Stone in 1982 that radio stations were not playing any of his songs off Mirage. He was still rebelling. Sleeping Angel was a Fleetwood Mac demo from the early years that Stevie did in 1982 for a movie soundtrack. Stevie had outrageously good material in 1982 and I would have wanted to give her another song for the best interests of the band. Oh Diane is a B side.
But I get it. The band felt the need to not be overshined but a huge solo star off the heals of Bella Donna.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:28 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
© 1995-2003 Martin and Lisa Adelson, All Rights Reserved